The manner in which Vincentius deals with this
letter has been very commonly thought, and with reason, to indicate a
Semipelagian leaning. E.g.
“Hunc locum Vincentius Lirinensis sic a vero sensu contra
Prosperum et Hilarium detorquet, ut ipse haud injuria in erroris
Semipelagiani suspicionem veniat.” The Benedictine editor of St.
Augustine’s works on Celestine’s letter, Tom. x. col. 2403.
To the same purpose, among others, Card.
Norris, Histor. Pelag., 246. Vossius, Histor. Pelag. Tillemont, T. xv. pp. 145, 862. Neander, Church History, iv. p. 388. His
“si ita est,” “if the case be so,”
emphasized by being repeated again and again, quite in an excited
manner, as we should say, shows an evident wish to shift the charge of
novelty from those against whom it had been brought, and fix it upon
the opposite party. “Who are the introducers of novelty? The
Massilians, as Prosper represents them, or their calumniators? Not the
Massilians: they notoriously appeal to antiquity,—not the
Massilians, but Prosper and the rest of Augustine’s
followers.”