94 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Boox rr.
leave you [as before], let us hear from you* how you say
that the soul, on being enwrapt in an earthly body, has no
recollection of the past; while, after being actually placed
in the body itself, and rendered almost senseless by union
with it, it holds tenaciously and faithfully the things which
many years before, eighty if you choose to say [so], or even
more, it either did, or suffered, or said, or heard. For if,
through being hampered by the body, it does not remember
those things which it knew long ago, and before it came into
this world,” there is more reason that it should forget those
things which it has done from time to time since being shut
up in the body, than those which [it did] before entering it,’
while not yet connected with men. For the same body which*
deprives of memory the soul which enters it,’ should cause
what is done within itself also to be wholly forgotten ; for one
cause cannot bring about two results, and [these] opposed to
each other, so as to make some things to be forgotten, [and]
allow others to be remembered by him who did them. But
if souls, as you call them, are prevented and hindered by
their [fleshly] members from recalling their former know-
ledge, how do they remember what has been arranged’ in
[these] very bodies, and know that they are spirits, and have
1 The Ms. reads ne videamu-s, changed in both Roman edd. into -amur
—''that we may not be seen by you [as ignorant], how say you,” ete.
Gelenius proposed the reading of the text, audiamus, which has been
received by Canterus and Orelli. It is clear from the next words—
quemadmodum dicitis—that in this case the verb must be treated as a
kind of interjection, ‘‘ How say you, let us hear." LB. reads, to much
the same purpose, scire avemus, ** we desire to know.”
? Lit., ** before man.” ? Lit., ** placed outside."
* Quod enim. 5 Rebus ingressis.
® So read by Orelli, artes suas antiquas, omitting atque, which, he says,
follows in the Ms. It is read after suas, however, in the first ed., and
those of Gelenius, Canterus, Hildebrand ; and according to Oehler, it
is so given in the MS., ‘‘its own and ancient.” Oberthiir would supply
res—'' its own arts and ancient things."
7 So the ms., reading constitut-a, followed by all edd. except those of
Ursinus, Hildebrand, and Oehler, who read -x, ** how do they remem-
ber when established in the bodies," which is certainly more in accord-
ance with the context.