Arianism stepped in with a summary answer. God is
one, numerically and absolutely. He is beyond the ken of any created
intelligence. Even creation is too close a relation for Him to enter
into with the world. In order to create, he must create an instrument
(pp. 360 sqq.), intermediate between Himself and all else. This
instrument is called Son of God, i.e. He is not coeternal (for what son
was ever as old as his parent?), but the result of an act of creative
will. How then is He different from other creatures? This is the weak
point of the system; He is not really different, but a difference is
created by investing Him with every possible attribute of glory and
divinity except the possession of the incommunicable nature of deity.
He is merely ‘anointed above His fellows.’ His
‘divinity’ is acquired, not original; relative, not
absolute; in His character, not in His Person. Accordingly He is, as a
creature, immeasurably far from the Creator; He does not know God,
cannot declare God to us. The One God remains in His inaccessible
remoteness from the creature. But yet Arians worshipped Christ;
although not very God, He is God to us. Here we have the exact
difficulty with which the Church started in her conflict with
heathenism presented again unsolved. The desperate struggle, the hardly
earned triumph of the Christians, had been for the sake of the
essential principle of heathenism! The One God was, after all, the God
of the philosophers; the idea of pagan polytheism was realised and
justified in Christ This
illustrates the famous paradox of Cardinal Newman (Development,
ed. 1878, pp. 142–4), that the condemnation of Arian Christology
left vacant a throne in heaven which the medieval Church
legitimately filled with the Blessed Virgin; that the Nicene
condemnation of the Arian theology is the vindication of the medieval;
that ‘the votaries of Mary do not exceed the true faith, unless
the blasphemers of her Son come up to it.’ But the question here
was one of worship, not of theology. The Arians
worshipped Christ, whom they regarded as a created being:
therefore, the Nicene fathers urge with one consent, they were
idolaters. The idea of a created being capable of being
worshipped was an Arian legacy to the Church, no doubt. But this
very idea, to Athanasius and Hilary, marked them out as idolaters. It
was reserved for later times ‘to find a subject for an Arian
predicate’ (Mozley). The argument is an astonishing
admission.! To this Athanasius
returns again and again (see esp. p. 360); it is the doom of Arianism
as a Christian theology.