REDUNDANT USE OF PRONOUNS. 57
sentences beginning with a participial clause, having
a subst. or pron. in it, and then in the principal
sentence have a pron. which is a mere repetition of
this. If they are in the same case and constr., the
second pronoun is redundant, not only in the sense
that it might be omitted without loss in clearness and
with gain in elegance, but in the sense of having no
proper place in the sentence : and if the foregoing
clause be a gen. abs., this is itself an irregular exten-
sion of the use of that constr., which is proper only
when there is no relation in the sentence calling for
another case.
We have e.g., a quite regular sentence in Matt. ix.
27, KOL TrapdyovTL eKi$i/ rw 'Irj(rov rjKoXovOrjcrav &vo
rv<Aot ; and so again in the next ver., IXQovri Se ets
rr]v oiKiav 7rpo(rf]\0av avrC) ol Tv<f>\oi. Again, it is
equally regular, when in ver. 32 we have a gen. abs.
introducing the next incident, avruv Se e^cp^o/xo/wv
iSov TrpocrrjveyKav avro) KOX^OJ/ 8aijU,oi/ioju,ei/oi/ But in
v. 1 we have (according to the more probable text)
a sentence constructed on the latter type where
grammatical rule calls for the former, /cafliVai/To? avrov
7rpocrr)X.6av aura) * ot fiaOrp-al avrov : so viii. 1,* 5,* 28,*
xxi. 23,* xxiv. 3, xxvi. 6, 7, and nearly so xvii. 22.
One may see a little more reason for the use of the
two cases in i. 18, 20, xxii. 41 : and in general, the
gen. abs. may be defended where the second mention
of its subject does rxot come till far on in the sentence,
or where (as in Mark v. 21) its case is not constructed
in relation to the main sentence, but depends upon a
* In the first passage there is high but limited authority for
omitting the pron.. and in the next four there is some, some-
times much, for assimilating the constr. to that of viii. 2!>.