flowers in your countrymen, you thought that I wrote in jest. As if, forsooth, in the midst
433
of evils of such magnitude we were in a mood for mirth. Certainly not. While the smoke
was ascending from the ruins of our church consumed by fire, were we likely to joke on the
subject? Although, indeed, none in your city appeared in my opinion innocent, but those
who were absent, or were sufferers, or were destitute both of strength and of authority to
prevent the tumult, I nevertheless distinguished in my reply those whose guilt was greater
from those who were less to blame, and stated that there was a difference between the cases
of those who were moved by fear of offending powerful enemies of the Church, and of those
who desired these outrages to be committed; also between those who committed them and
those who instigated others to their commission; resolving, however, not to institute inquiry
in regard to the instigators, because these, perhaps, could not be ascertained without recourse
to the use of tortures, from which we shrink with abhorrence, as utterly inconsistent with
our aims. Your friends the Stoics, who hold that all faults are alike, must, however, if they
were the judges, pronounce them all equally guilty; and if to this opinion they join that in-
flexible sternness wherewith they disparage clemency as a vice, their sentence would neces-
sarily be, not that all should be pardoned alike, but that all should be punished alike. Dismiss,
therefore, these philosophers altogether from the position of advocates in this case, and
rather desire that we may act as Christians, so that, as we desire, we may gain in Christ those
whom we forgive, and may not spare them by such indulgence as would be ruinous to
themselves. May God, whose ways are mercy and truth, be pleased to enrich you with true
felicity!
941
To Nectarius