I ask pardon from the mercy of that One in whom we have hope of liberation from all the
errors of heretics.
Fortunatus said: You asseverate that we say that God is cruel in sending the soul, but
that God made man, breathed into him a soul which assuredly He foreknew to be involved
in future misery, and not to be able by reason of evils to be restored to its inheritance. This
belongs either to one who is ignorant, or who gives the soul up to these aforesaid evils. This
I have cited because you said not long since, that God adopted the soul, not that it is from
Him; for to adopt is a different matter.
29. Augustin said: Concerning adoption I remember that I spoke some days ago ac-
cording to the testimony of the apostle, who says that we have been called into the adoption
of sons.261 This was not my reply, therefore, but the apostle’s, concerning which thing, that
is, that adoption, we may inquire, if we please, in its own time; and concerning that I will
reply without delay, when you shall have answered my objections.
Fortunatus said: I say that there was a going forth of the soul against a contrary nature,
which nature could not injure God.
30. Augustin said: What need was there for that going forth, when God whom nothing
could injure had nothing to protect?
Fortunatus said: Do you conscientiously hold that Christ came from God?
31. Augustin said: Again you are questioning me. Reply to my inquiries.
Fortunatus said: So I have received in faith, that by the will of God He came hither.
32. Augustin said: And I say: Why did God, omnipotent, inviolable, immutable, whom
nothing could injure, send hither the soul, to miseries, to error, to those things that we suffer?
Fortunatussaid: For it has been said: "I have power to lay down my soul and I have
power to take it again."262 Now He said that by the will of God the soul went forth.
33. Augustin said: I ask for the reason why God, when He can in no way suffer injury,
sent the soul hither?
Fortunatus said: We have already said that God can in no way suffer injury, and we
have said that the soul is in a contrary nature, therefore that it imposes a limit on the contrary
nature. The restraint having been imposed on the contrary nature, God takes the same.
For He Himself said, "I have power to lay down my soul and power to take it." The Father
gave to me the power of laying down my soul, and of taking it. To what soul, therefore, did
God who spoke in the Son refer? Evidently our soul, which is held in these bodies, which
came of His will, and of His will is again taken up.
261 Eph. i. 5.
262 John x. 18.
205
Disputation of the Second Day.