Now the drift of Eunomius’
excessive concern about the Ungenerate has been often explained before;
and it shall here be briefly discovered yet again. For as the term
Father points to no difference of nature from the Son, his impiety, if
he had brought his statement to a close here, would have had no
support, seeing that the natural sense of the names Father and Son
excludes the idea of their being alien in essence. But as it is, by
employing the terms “generate” and
“ungenerate,” since the contradictory opposition between
them admits of no mean, just like that between “mortal” and
“immortal,” “rational” and
“irrational,” and all those terms which are opposed to each
other by the mutually exclusive nature of their meaning,—by the
use of these terms, I repeat, he gives free course to his profanity, so
as to contemplate as existing in the “generate” with
reference to the “ungenerate” the same difference which
there is between “mortal” and “immortal”: and
even as the nature of the mortal is one, and that of the immortal
another, and as the special attributes of the rational and of the
irrational are essentially incompatible, just so he wants to make out
that the nature of the ungenerate is one, and that of the generate
another, in order to show that as the irrational nature has been
created in subjection to the rational, so the generate is by a
necessity of its being in a state of subordination to the ungenerate.
For which reason he attaches to the ungenerate the name of
“Almighty,” and this he does not apply to express
providential operation, as the argument led the way for him in
suggesting, but transfers the application of the word to arbitrary
sovereignty, so as to make the Son to be a part of the subject and
subordinate universe, a fellow-slave with all the rest to Him Who with
arbitrary and absolute sovereignty controls all alike. And that it is
with an eye to this result that he employs these argumentative
distinctions, will be clearly established from the passage before us.
For after those sapient and carefully-considered expressions, that He
is not like either as Father to Father, or as Son to Son,—and yet
there is no necessity that father should invariably be like father or
son like son: for suppose there is one father among the Ethiopians, and
another among the Scythians, and each of these has a son, the
Ethiopian’s son black, but the Scythian white-skinned and with
hair of a golden tinge, yet none the more because each is a father does
the Scythian turn black on the Ethiopian’s account, nor does the
Ethiopian’s body change to white on account of the
Scythian,—after saying this, however, according to his own fancy,
Eunomius subjoins that “He is like as Son to Father This is
apparently a quotation from Eunomius in continuation of what has gone
before..” But although such a phrase indicates
kinship in nature, as the inspired Scripture attests in the case of
Seth and Adam, our doctor, with but small respect for his intelligent
readers, introduces his idle exposition of the title “Son,”
defining Him to be the image and seal of the energy The
word employed is ἐνέργεια; which might be translated by “active force,” or
“operation,” as elsewhere.
of the Almighty. “For the Son,” he says, “is the
image and seal of the energy of the Almighty.” Let him who hath
ears to hear first, I pray, consider this particular point—What
is “the seal of the energy”? Every energy is contemplated
as exertion in the party who exhibits it, and on the completion of his
exertion, it has no independent existence. Thus, for example, the
energy of the runner is the motion of his feet, and when the motion has
stopped there is no longer any energy. So too about every pursuit the
same may be said;—when the exertion of him who is busied about
anything ceases, the energy ceases also, and has no independent
existence, either when a person is actively engaged in the exertion he
undertakes, or when he ceases from that exertion. What then does he
tell us that the energy is in itself, which is neither essence, nor
image, nor person? So he speaks of the Son as the similitude of the
impersonal, and that which is like the non-existent surely has itself
no existence at all. This is what his juggling with idle opinions comes
to,—belief in nonentity! for that which is like nonentity
surely itself is not. O Paul and John and all you others of the band of
Apostles and Evangelists, who are they that arm their venomous tongues
against your words? who are they that raise their frog-like croakings
against your heavenly thunder? What then saith the son of thunder?
“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and
the Word was God S. John i. 1.” And what
saith he that came after him, that other who had been within the
heavenly temple, who in Paradise had been initiated into mysteries
unspeakable? “Being,” he says, “the Brightness of His
glory, and the express Image of His person Heb. i. 3..” What, after these have thus spoken,
are the words of our ventriloquist Cf. the
use of ἐγγαστρίμυθος
in LXX. (e.g. Lev. xix. 31, Is. xliv.
25).? “The
seal,” quoth he, “of the energy of the Almighty.” He
makes Him third after the Father, with that non-existent energy
mediating between them, or rather moulded at pleasure by non-existence.
God the Word, Who was in the beginning, is “the seal of the
energy”:—the Only-begotten God, Who is contemplated in the
eternity of the Beginning of existent things, Who is in the bosom of
the Father S. John i. 18, Who sustains all things, by the word
of His power Cf. Heb. i. 3, the creator of the ages, from Whom and
through Whom and in Whom are all things Cf. Rom. xi. 36, Who
sitteth upon the circle of the earth, and hath meted out heaven with
the span, Who measureth the water in the hollow of his hand Cf. Isa. xl. 12–22., Who holdeth in His hand all things that are,
Who dwelleth on high and looketh upon the things that are lowly Cf. Ps. cxxxviii. 6., or rather did look upon them to make all the
world to be His footstool Cf. Isa. lxvi. 1, imprinted by the
footmark of the Word—the form of God Cf. Phil. ii. 5 is
“the seal” of an “energy.” Is God then an
energy, not a Person? Surely Paul when expounding this very truth says
He is “the express image,” not of His energy, but “of
His Person.” Is the Brightness of His glory a seal of the energy
of God? Alas for his impious ignorance! What is there intermediate
between God and His own form? and Whom does the Person employ as
mediator with His own express image? and what can be conceived as
coming between the glory and its brightness? But while there are such
weighty and numerous testimonies wherein the greatness of the Lord of
the creation is proclaimed by those who were entrusted with the
proclamation of the Gospel, what sort of language does this forerunner
of the final apostasy hold concerning Him? What says he? “As
image,” he says, “and seal of all the energy and power of
the Almighty.” How does he take upon himself to emend the words
of the mighty Paul? Paul says that the Son is “the Power of God 1 Cor. i. 24.”; Eunomius calls Him “the seal of
a power,” not the Power. And then, repeating his expression, what
is it that he adds to his previous statement? He calls Him “seal
of the Father’s works and words and counsels.” To what
works of the Father is He like? He will say, of course, the world, and
all things that are therein. But the Gospel has testified that all
these things are the works of the Only-begotten. To what works of the
Father, then, was He likened? of what works was He made the seal? what
Scripture ever entitled Him “seal of the Father’s
works”? But if any one should grant Eunomius the right to fashion
his words at his own will, as he desires, even though Scripture does
not agree with him, let him tell us what works of the Father there are
of which he says that the Son was made the seal, apart from those that
have been wrought by the Son. All things visible and invisible are the
work of the Son: in the visible are included the whole world and all
that is therein; in the invisible, the supramundane creation. What
works of the Father, then, are remaining to be contemplated by
themselves, over and above things visible and invisible, whereof he
says that the Son was made the “seal”? Will he perhaps,
when driven into a corner, return once more to the fetid vomit of
heresy, and say that the Son is a work of the Father? How then does the
Son come to be the seal of these works when He Himself, as Eunomius
says, is the work of the Father? Or does he say that the same Person is
at once a work and the likeness of a work? Let this be granted: let us
suppose him to speak of the other works of which he says the Father was
the creator, if indeed he intends us to understand likeness by the term
“seal.” But what other “words” of the Father
does Eunomius know, besides that Word Who was ever in the Father, Whom
he calls a “seal”—Him Who is and is called the Word
in the absolute, true, and primary sense? And to what counsels can he
possibly refer, apart from the Wisdom of God, to which the Wisdom of
God is made like, in becoming a “seal” of those counsels?
Look at the want of discrimination and circumspection, at the confused
muddle of his statement, how he brings the mystery into ridicule,
without understanding either what he says or what he is arguing about.
For He Who has the Father in His entirety in Himself, and is Himself in
His entirety in the Father, as Word and Wisdom and Power and Truth, as
His express image and brightness, Himself is all things in the Father,
and does not come to be the image and seal and likeness of certain
other things discerned in the Father prior to Himself.