to one, that there is one false among them; and as likely as not that there are ten false ones
in the whole hundred. And the probability of the individuals must be much greater than
ten to one, even a probability of more than a hundred to one in order to its making it probable
that every one is true. It is an easy mathematical demonstration. Hence the negative of the
foregoing question by no means implies a pretence of any scheme, that shall be effectual to
keep all hypocrites out of the church, and for the establishing in that sense a pure church.
When it is said, those who are admitted, &c. ought to be by profession godly or gracious
persons; it is not meant, they should merely profess or say that they are converted or are
gracious persons, that they know so, or think so; but that they profess the great things wherein
christian piety consists, viz. a supreme respect to God, faith in Christ, &c. Indeed it is neces-
sary, as men would keep a good conscience, that they should think that these things are in
them, which they profess to be in them; otherwise they are guilty of the horrid wickedness
of willfully making a lying profession. Hence it is supposed to be necessary, in order to men’s
regularly and with a good conscience coming into communion with the church of Christ
in the christian sacraments, that they themselves should suppose the essential things, belong-
ing to christian piety, to be in them.
It does not belong to the present question, to consider and determine what the nature
of christian piety is, or wherein it consists: this question may be properly determined, and
the determination demonstrated, without entering into any controversies about the nature
of conversion, &c. Nor does an asserting the negative of the question determine any thing
how particular the profession of godliness ought to be, but only that the more essential
things, which belong to it, ought to be professed. Nor is it determined, but that the public
professions made on occasion of persons’ admission to the Lord’s supper, in some of our
churches, who yet go upon that principle, that persons need not esteem themselves truly
gracious in order to a coming conscientiously and properly to the Lord’s supper; I say, it is
not determined but that some of these professions are sufficient, if those that made them
were taught to use the words, and others to understand them, in no other than their proper
meaning, and principle and custom had not established a meaning very diverse from it, or
perhaps an use of the words without any distinct and clear determinate meaning.
1752
PART I. The Question stated and explained.