in some mysterious way; but if material existence was in Him, how can He be immaterial
while including matter in Himself? and similarly with all the other marks by which the
material nature is differentiated; if quantity exists in God, how is God without quantity? if
the compound nature exists in Him, how is He simple, without parts and without combin-
ation? so that the argument forces us to think either that He is material, because matter has
its existence from Him as a source; or, if one avoids this, it is necessary to suppose that
matter was imported by Him ab extra for the making of the universe.
4. If, then, it was external to God, something else surely existed besides God, conceived,
in respect of eternity, together with Him Who exists ungenerately; so that the argument
supposes two eternal and unbegotten existences, having their being concurrently with each
413
other—that of Him Who operates as an artificer, and that of the thing which admits this
skilled operation; and if any one under pressure of this argument should assume a material
substratum for the Creator of all things, what a support will the Manichæan find for his
special doctrine, who opposes by virtue of ungenerateness a material existence to a Good
Being. Yet we do believe that all things are of God, as we hear the Scripture say so; and as
to the question how they were in God, a question beyond our reason, we do not seek to pry
into it, believing that all things are within the capacity of God’s power—both to give existence
to what is not, and to implant qualities at His pleasure in what is.
5. Consequently, as we suppose the power of the Divine will to be a sufficient cause to
the things that are, for their coming into existence out of nothing, so too we shall not repose
our belief on anything beyond probability in referring the World-Reformation to the same
power. Moreover, it might perhaps be possible, by some skill in the use of words, to persuade
those who raise frivolous objections on the subject of matter not to think that they can make
an unanswerable attack on our statement.
769
That he who confesses the beginning of the world's existence must necessarily…