9. Respecting vigils and the frequent keeping of
night-watches in the basilicas of the martyrs, I have given a brief
reply in another letter Letter CIX. which, about
two years ago, I wrote to the reverend presbyter Riparius. You argue
that they ought to be abjured, lest we seem to be often keeping Easter,
and appear not to observe the customary yearly vigils. If so, then
sacrifices should not be offered to Christ on the Lord’s day lest
we frequently keep the Easter of our Lord’s Resurrection, and
introduce the custom of having many Easters instead of one. We must
not, however, impute to pious men the faults and errors of youths and
worthless women such as are often detected at night. It is true that,
even at the Easter vigils, something of the kind usually comes to
light; but the faults of a few form no argument against religion in
general, and such persons, without keeping vigil, can go wrong either
in their own houses or in those of other people. The treachery of Judas
did not annul the loyalty of the Apostles. And if others keep vigil
badly, our vigils are not thereby to be stopped; nay, rather let those
who sleep to gratify their lust be compelled to watch that they may
preserve their chastity. For if a thing once done be good, it cannot be
bad if often done; and if there is some fault to be avoided, the blame
lies not in its being done often, but in its being done at all. And so
we should not watch at Easter-tide for fear that adulterers may satisfy
their long pent-up desires, or that the wife may find an opportunity
for sinning without having the key turned against her by her husband.
The occasions which seldom recur are those which are most eagerly
longed for.