Chapter II.—The Disputation of Nebridius Against the Manichæans, on the Question
“Whether God Be Corruptible or Incorruptible.”
3. It was sufficient for me, O Lord, to oppose to those deceived deceivers and dumb
praters (dumb, since Thy word sounded not forth from them) that which a long while ago,
while we were at Carthage, Nebridius used to propound, at which all we who heard it were
disturbed: “What could that reputed nation of darkness, which the Manichæans are in the
habit of setting up as a mass opposed to Thee, have done unto Thee hadst Thou objected
to fight with it? For had it been answered, ‘It would have done Thee some injury,’ then
shouldest Thou be subject to violence and corruption; but if the reply were: ‘It could do
Thee no injury,’ then was no cause assigned for Thy fighting with it; and so fighting as that
a certain portion and member of Thee, or offspring of Thy very substance, should be blended
with adverse powers and natures not of Thy creation, and be by them corrupted and deteri-
orated to such an extent as to be turned from happiness into misery, and need help whereby
it might be delivered and purged; and that this offspring of Thy substance was the soul, to
which, being enslaved, contaminated, and corrupted, Thy word, free, pure, and entire, might
bring succour; but yet also the word itself being corruptible, because it was from one and
the same substance. So that should they affirm Thee, whatsoever Thou art, that is, Thy
substance whereby Thou art, to be incorruptible, then were all these assertions false and
execrable; but if corruptible, then that were false, and at the first utterance to be abhorred.”484
484 Similar arguments are made use of in his controversy with Fortunatus (Dis. ii. 5), where he says, that as
Fortunatus could find no answer, so neither could he when a Manichæan, and that this led him to the true faith.
Again, in his De Moribus (sec. 25), where he examines the answers which had been given, he commences: “For
this gives rise to the question, which used to throw us into great perplexity, even when we were your zealous
disciples, nor could we find any answer,—what the race of darkness would have done to God, supposing He
had refused to fight with it at the cost of such calamity to part of Himself. For if God would not have suffered
any loss by remaining quiet, we thought it hard that we had been sent to endure so much. Again, if He would
have suffered, His nature cannot have been incorruptible, as it behooves the nature of God to be.” We have
already, in the note to book iv. sec. 26, referred to some of the matters touched on in this section; but they call
for further elucidation. The following passage, quoted by Augustin from Manichæus himself (Con. Ep. Manich.
19), discloses to us (1) their ideas as to the nature and position of the two kingdoms: “In one direction, on the
border of this bright and holy region, there was a land of darkness, deep and vast in extent, where abode fiery
bodies, destructive races. Here was boundless darkness flowing from the same source in immeasurable abundance,
with the productions properly belonging to it. Beyond this were muddy, turbid waters with their inhabitants;
and inside of them winds terrible and violent, with their prince and their progenitors. Then, again, a fiery region
of destruction, with its chiefs and peoples. And similarly inside of this, a race full of smoke and gloom, where
abode the dreadful prince and chief of all, having around him innumerable princes, himself the mind and source
of them all. Such are the five natures of the region of corruption.” Augustin also designates them (ibid. sec. 20)
“the five dens of the race of darkness.” The nation of darkness desires to possess the kingdom of light, and prepares
The Disputation of Nebridius Against the Manichæans, on the Question ‘Whether God Be Corruptible or Incorruptible.’
218
The Disputation of Nebridius Against the Manichæans, on the Question ‘Whether…