deterrent to the bringing in of any charges against the guilty. He asks for a republication
of the repressive laws, since the enemy is boasting of their repeal.
Augustin wrote a general letter to the Donatist people in c. 409 [Ep. cv.], in which he
declares that the Catholic effort at their conversion is the work of peacemakers. Some
Donatist presbyters had ordered the Catholics to let their people alone, if they did not want
to be killed, but Augustin would all the rather ask the people to recede from the schismatics
because they were separated from that body for which Christ died. Catholics must seek for
the stolen sheep that had on them the mark of Christ. The charge of being traditors, says
he, we meet with a like accusation against you, and then you bid us leave. You claim to be
the Church on this unproved charge, unmindful of what law, prophecy, Psalms, Apostles
and Gospels say as to its universality beginning at Jerusalem. You are not in communion
with that universal body, and you prevent the escape of others from a similar perdition.
390
The objection as to persecution he meets with an invitation to look at the deeds of clergy
and Circumcelliones, and cites instances of grievous ill-treatment toward voluntary converts:
Marcus, presbyter of Casphalia, Restitutus of Victoria, Marcianus of Urga, Maximinus and
Possidius, and then protests against their general violence and robberies, and especially
against attributing martyrdom to those who had only been punished for their crimes. To
all this compulsion we oppose the State, he affirms, and many of your own people rejoice
in deliverance from your oppressions. You have filled Africa with false charges as to Cæcilian,
Felix, etc., and though we do not place our hope in man, yet we do recognize the State as
the servant of the Church. Nebuchadnezzar is an example both of the persecutor and the
correctionist. You despise the baptism of Christ; ought this not to be punished? He then
reviews the history of the case in the light of the documents; commenting on them as forms
of their own appeal to the State. The liberty of error is most deadly to the soul. Christ and
the Apostles command unity, and this command the Emperors seek to enforce. Only Julian
and the heathen emperors were persecutors; the only martyrs are those who suffer for
Catholic truth. The whole imperial legislation against Donatism is the outcome of the ori-
ginal statute of Constantine and sprang after all from their appeal. He next discusses their
view of baptism and insists that the rite is independent of the character of the celebrant;
were it dependent, then, according to their notion, we should rather desire to be baptized
by a bad man, in order to receive the grace directly from Christ. The appeal to unity follows.
Make concord with us he urges; we love you and desire to serve you, even by the aid of the
temporal laws; we do not want you to perish as aliens from your Catholic mother. Your
charges you are unable to substantiate, and yet you avoid all conference with us, as if to
shun fellowship with sinners; a false pride, which is rebuked by Paul’s conduct, by the Lord’s
in his treatment of Judas; the Lord held conference even with the devil. This he follows with
extended Scriptural proofs of the universality of the Church. He reminds them again of the
unproved charges which apply rather to themselves; but he has no desire for the historical
670
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.