We come now to the only other argument brought against
the ecumenical character of this council—to wit, that many
writers, even until after the beginning of the XVIth century, call the Seventh a
“pseudo-Council.” But surely this proves too much,
for it would seem to imply that even down to that time the cultus of
images was not established in the West, a proposition too ridiculous to
be defended by anyone. It is indeed worthy of notice that
all the authors cited are Frankish,
(1) the Annales Francorum (a.d. 808) in
the continuation of the same (a.d. 814), in an
anonymous life of Charlemagne, and the Annales written after
819; (2) Eginhard in his Annales Francorum (a.d. 829); (3) the Gallican bishops at Paris, 824; The true date is
825. (4) Hincmar of Rheims; (5) Ado, bishop of
Vienne (died 875); (6) Anastasius acknowledges that the French had not
accepted the veneration of the sacred images; (7) The Chronicle of
St. Bertinus (after 884); (8) The Annales Francorum after
the council still speak of it as pseudo; (9) Regino, Abbot of Prum
(circa 910); (10) the Chronicle of St. Bertinus, of the
Xth Century. (11) Hermanus Contractus: (12) the
author who continued the Gestes Francorum to a.d. 1165; (13) Roger Hoverden (a.d. 1204); (14) Conrade à Lichtenau, Abbot of Urspurg
(circa 1230); (15) Matthew of Westminster.