The Origenist bishops of Syria and Asia Minor had
in the years 269–272, after several efforts, succeeded in
deposing Paul of Samosata from the See of
Antioch. This remarkable man was the ablest pre-Nicene representative
of Adoptionist Monarchianism. The Man Jesus was inhabited by the
‘Word,’ i.e. by an impersonal power of God, distinct
from the Λόγος or
reason (wisdom) inherent in God as an attribute, which descended upon
him at His Baptism. His union with God, a union of Will, was
unswerving, and by virtue of it He overcame the sin of mankind, worked
miracles, and entered on a condition of Deification. He is God ἐκ
προκοπῆς (cf. Luke ii. 52) by virtue of progress in perfection.
That is in brief the system of Paul, and we cannot wonder at his
deposition. For the striking points of contact with Arianism (two
‘Wisdoms,’ two ‘Words,’ προκοπή: cf. Orat.
c. Ar. i. 5, &c.) we have to account The
theological genesis of Paul’s system is obscure. The theory of
Newman that he was under strong Jewish influences is largely based upon
the late and apparently quite erroneous tradition that his patroness
Zenobia was a Jewess; see p. 296, note 9a, and Gwatkin, p.
57, and note 3. Harnack regards him as the representative of
‘archaic’ East-Syrian adoptionism such as pervades the
‘Discussion of Archelaus with Manes;’ see Routh,
Rell. v. especially pp. 178–184. But Paul would not have
spoken of Mary as ‘Dei Genetrix,’ p. 128; I cannot see more
in these ‘Acta’ than a naive adoptionism homologous to the
‘naive modalism’ of much early Christian language, but like
it not representative of the entire view of those who use it; we must
also note that the statements of ‘Archelaus’ are coloured
by reaction against the docetism of ‘Manes;’ but Paul may
well have taken up this naive adoptionism, and, by strict
Aristotelian logic, developed it as the exclusive basis of his
system. Whether Paul’s use of the idea of the Logos betrays the
faintest influence of Origen is to me, at least, extremely
uncertain.. The
theology of Arius is a compromise between the Origenist doctrine of the
Person of Christ and the pure Monarchian Adoptionism of Paul of
Samosata; or rather it engrafts the former upon the latter as the foundation principle, seriously modifying
each to suit the necessity of combining the two. This compromise was
not due to Arius himself but to his teacher, Lucian the Martyr. A native himself of Samosata, he stood
in some relation of attachment (not clearly defineable) to Paul. Under
him, he was at the head of a critical, exegetical, and theological
school at Antioch. Upon the deposition of Paul he appears not so much
to have been formally excommunicated as to have refused to acquiesce in
the new order of things. Under Domnus and his two successors, he was in
a state of suspended communion ἀποσυνάγωγος
ἔμεινεν,
Alex. Alexand. in Thdt.; the objections of Gwatkin, p. 18, note, are
generously meant rather than convincing: the ‘creed of
Lucian’ is not usable without discrimination for Lucian’s
position: see discussion by Caspari A.u.N.Q. p. 42,
note.; but eventually was
reconciled with the bishop (Cyril?) and died as a martyr at Nicomedia,
Jan. 7, 312. The latter fact, his ascetic life, and his learning
secured him widespread honour in the Church; his pupils formed a
compact and enthusiastic brotherhood, and filled many of the most
influential Sees after the persecution. That such a man should be
involved in the reproach of having given birth to Arianism is an
unwelcome result of history, but one not to be evaded. 598,
ii. 183 sqq. must, I think, convince any open mind
of the fact. Consult his article on Lucian in Herzog2. viii.
767 (the best investigation), also Neander H. E. ii. 198, iv.
108; Möller K.G. i. 226, D.C.B. iii. 748; Kölling,
vol. 1, pp. 27–31, who makes the mistake of taking the
‘Lucianic creed’ as his point of departure..
The history of the Lucianic compromise and its result in the Lucianic
type of theology, are both matters of inference rather than of direct
knowledge. As to the first, whatever evidence there is connects
Lucian’s original position with Paul. His reconciliation with
Bishop Cyril must have involved a reapproachment to the formula of the
bishops who deposed Paul,—a thoroughly Origenist document. We may
therefore suppose that the identification of Christ with the
Logos, or cosmic divine principle, was adopted by him from Origenist
sources. But he could not bring himself to admit that He was thus
essentially identified with God the eternal; he held fast to the idea
of προκοπή
as the path by which the Lord attained to Divinity; he distinguished
the Word or Son who was Christ from the immanent impersonal Reason or
Wisdom of God, as an offspring of the Father’s Will, an
idea which he may have derived straight from Origen, with whom of
course it had a different sense. For to Origen Will was the very
essence of God; Lucian fell back upon an arid philosophical Monotheism,
upon an abstract God fenced about with negations (Harnack
22, 195, note) and remote from the Universe. It was counted
a departure from Lucian’s principles if a pupil held that the Son
was the ‘perfect Image of the Father’s Essence’
(Philost. ii. 15); Origen’s formula, ‘distinct in
hypostasis, but one in will,’ was apparently exploited in a
Samosatene sense to express the relation of the Son to the Father.
The only two points in fact in which Lucian appears to have modified
the system of Paul were, firstly in hypostatising the Logos,
which to Paul was an impersonal divine power, secondly in
abandoning Paul’s purely human doctrine of the historical Christ.
To Lucian, the Logos assumed a body (or rather ‘Deus
sapientiam suam misit in hunc mundum carne vestitam,
ubi infra, p. 6), but itself took the place of a soul This is
ascribed to Lucian by Epiph. Ancor. 33, and there is no reason
whatever to doubt it. The tenet was part of the Arian system from the
first, and was attacked already by Eustathius, Fragm. apud Thdt.
Dial. iii., but often overlooked, e.g. even by Athanasius in his
writings before 362, but see p. 352, note 5. It came to the front in
the system of Eunomius, and was much discussed in the last decade of
the life of S. Athan. The system of Apollinaris was different. (See pp.
570, note 1, 575, note 1.); hence all the ταπειναὶ
λέξεις of the Gospels applied to
the Logos as such, and the inferiority and essential difference
of the Son from the Father rigidly followed.