beginning and an end. Manes said: But in that way it would also follow that God was its
maker. Archelaus said: By no means; away with such a supposition! “For God made not
death; neither hath He pleasure in the destruction of the living.”1715 Manes said: God made
it not; nevertheless it was made, as you admit. Tell us, therefore, from whom it received its
empire, or by whom it was created. Archelaus said: If I give the most ample proof of the fact
that death cannot have the substance of an unbegotten nature, will you not confess that
there is but one God, and that an unbegotten God? Manes said: Continue your discourse,
for your aim is to speak1716 with subtlety. Archelaus said: Nay, but you have put forward
those allegations in such a manner, as if they were to serve you for a demonstration of an
unbegotten root. Nevertheless the positions which we have discussed above may suffice us,
for by these we have shown most fully that it is impossible for the substances of two unbe-
gotten natures to exist together.
1715 Wisd. i. 13.
1716 The text gives discere, to learn; but dicere seems the probable reading.
475
Chapter XXIX.