1850-1] MAZZINI ON COMMUNISM 83
Emily sends word that she has had the " clan " to see
her for the first time ; Mazzini got into a long talk, chiefly
with Mr. Stansfeld, that was most interesting. I think I
must copy that bit for you, as you worship Mazzini.
"
[It was] about property and communism, and how
man had no abstract rights, as the Americans put it, only
duties, and the right to perform those duties ; and
'
liberty,
fraternity, and equality
'
is a false cry as commonly under-
stood, and a bad one anyhow ; and man's life is a task
the task to transform what is around and in him into
something higher. Then you see came morals, politics,
art, religion : all man's activity being in truth a trans-
forming ; and the things produced the sign of his activity ;
and property the outward sign of the transforming power
he has exerted for use, as art is for beauty in the external
world, and therefore as sacred in its origin as any of them.
'Yes, but,' Mr. Stansfeld said (he was arguing for com-
munism as ideally possible),
'
why might not all property
be vested in Society ?
' '
Because that was nonsense,'
Mazzini said.
'
Society .abstractedly was nothing: Society
really was a collection of individuals ; individuals did the
work, therefore individuals got the property ; they might
give it away if they liked, but the right to it was in them-
selves.' And so the discussion went on for two hours as
interesting as possible, Mazzini getting quite eager and
pettish, as he is with people he is fond of; telling Mr.
Stansfeld he was crotchetty, morbid, &c."
EMILY to CATHERINE
BEDFORD Row, Deer, iqth, 1851.
Oh dear ! I wish I could keep a journal ; things pass
away so fast. I wanted to tell you all about the night
when little Louis Blanc came to us for the first time. The
little Frenchman really did talk splendidly. Not the
highest style of talk, because not varied enough, but a
perpetual flow on all subjects great and little of the