The apostle does not say that there can be no sin if there is no
law. He says the exact contrary. He elsewhere says (iv. 15) that where there is no law there is no
transgression. By “law” here he means positive,
statutory commands and prohibitions. His meaning here is: God does not
reckon ἁμαρτία as παράβασις
where there is no explicit commandment. But sin was in
the world during all this period previous to the Mosaic law, as proved
by the reign of death. It extended its sway and penalty even to those
who had not sinned, as Adam did, against positive enactment. We know
well on what principle the apostle justifies his position that there is
sin even where no written commandment is transgressed. The principle
has been already developed viz.: there is a moral law implanted in the
human heart (i. 19, 21; ii.
15).
To offend against this is sin (though not transgression, which implies
positive law) and induces death as its
consequence.—G.B.S.