John Jejunator
(or the Faster), so called from his ascetic habits. Gregory had
known and esteemed him during his residence at Constantinople.
See above, III. 4. The occasion of the letter before us was as
follows. Two presbyters, John of Chalcedon and Athanasius of
Isauria (the latter being also a monk in the monastery of St. Mile in
Isauria), had been accused of heresy at Constantinople, found guilty,
and one of them beaten with cudgels in the church. They had gone
to Rome to lay their grievances before the pope, who had written to
John Jejunator the Patriarch more than once to protest against so
uncanonical a punishment. The Patriarch seems to have replied
that he knew nothing about the matter: whereupon Gregory sent him
this stinging letter. In the following year (593–4), it
appears from a letter to Narses, a patrician at Constantinople, that
the case was still pending. Narses had reported the Patriarch as
wishing to act canonically; and Gregory, doubtfully hoping so,
threatens strong measures if it should be otherwise (IV. 32).
Afterwards (a.d. 594–5) it seems as if
the Patriarch had written on the subject pleasantly: for at the
end of a long letter to him protesting against his assumption of the
title of “Œcumenical Bishop,” Gregory alludes
to his “scripta dulcissima atque suavissima” in the
matter of John and Athanasius, promising a reply (V. 18). In the
following year (a.d. 595–6) we find that
the charges of heresy against the two presbyters had been entertained
before Gregory in a Roman synod; and this apparently with the assent of
the Patriarch, who had transmitted a statement of the case. John
of Chalcedon had been fully acquitted of heresy; but some doubt still
remained as to the orthodoxy of Athanasius. Accordingly John was
at once sent back to Constantinople with a letter from Gregory to the
Patriarch, reversing the sentence against him which had been passed at
Constantinople and demanding that he should be received with favour and
reinstated. As though doubtful of the Patriarch’s
compliance, Gregory addressed also the Emperor, and Theoctistus, a
relation of the Emperor’s, requesting them to protect the
acquitted appellant (VI. 14, 15, 16, 17). In the same year
Athanasius, who had explained or retracted what had been objected to in
his writings, was also declared orthodox, and sent back to
Constantinople as acquitted. But this was after the death of John
Jejunator; and accordingly the letter demanding the reinstatement of
Athanasius was addressed to his successor Cyriacus (VI. 66; VII.
5). How John Jejunator would have acted at this stage of the
proceedings, had he lived, we have no means of knowing; nor is there
record of the action of Cyriacus. The only further reference to
the subject in the epistles is in one to the two Patriarchs of
Alexandria and Antioch (VII. 34), in writing to whom Gregory sets forth
at some length the doctrinal questions that had been treated in the
trial of Athanasius, as though desirous of having the assent of those
apostolical and patriarchal sees, which (as we have seen) he elsewhere
acknowledges as sharing with his own the authority of St. Peter, to the
decision come to at Rome. The whole history of the case, which,
as has been seen, was protracted through several years, is of some
importance as illustrating Gregory’s claim to entertain appeals
from Constantinople, and to reverse at Rome what had been decided
there, though it is not equally clear, from what is before us in this
particular case, how such claims were viewed at Constantinople.
On the one hand we find no sign of the appeal of the two presbyters to
Rome having been objected to; while on the other, Gregory evidently had
his doubts as to whether the Roman decision would be acted on at
Constantinople; and whether it was so or not we do not know. The
letters about it, above referred to, are III. 53; IV. 32; V. 18; VI.
14, 15, 16, 17, 66; VII. 5, 34.