There has been some difference of opinion among the
learned as to whether St. Cyril’s Synodal letter which has at its
end the anathemas against Nestorius, which hereafter follow, was
formally approved at the Council of Ephesus. The matter is one
only of archeological and historical interest, for from a theological
point of view the question is entirely uninteresting, since there is no
possible doubt that the synod endorsed St. Cyril’s teaching and
for that express reason proceeded at their first session to
excommunicate Nestorius. Further there is no one that disputes
that the anathematisms were received at the next General Council. i.e.,
of Chalcedon, only twenty years later, and that Theodoret was condemned
by the Fifth Ecumenical Council because he wrote against these very
Anathemas. This being the
case, to those who value the decrees of Ecumenical Councils because of
their ecumenical character, it is quite immaterial whether these
anathematisms were received and approved by the third Council or no,
provided, which is indisputably the case, they have been approved by
some one council of ecumenical authority, so as to become thereby part
and parcel of the ecumenical faith of the Church.