523
Introduction.
Gibbon thus describes the Seventh Ecumenical Council of the Christian Church: “The
decrees were framed by the president507 Tarasius, and ratified by the acclamations and
subscriptions of three hundred and fifty bishops. They unanimously pronounced that the
worship of images is agreeable to Scripture and reason, to the Fathers and councils of the
Church; but they hesitated whether that worship be relative or direct; whether the godhead
and the figure of Christ be entitled to the same mode of adoration.508 Of this second Nicene
Council the acts are still extant; a curious monument of superstition and ignorance, of
falsehood and folly.” (Decline and Fall, chapter xlix.)
And this has been read as history, and has passed as such in the estimation of the over-
whelming majority of educated English-speaking people for several generations, and yet it
is a statement as full of absolute and inexcusable errors as the passage in another part of the
same work which the late Bishop Lightfoot so unmercifully exposed, and which the most
recent editor, Bury, has taken pains to correct.
I do not know whether it is worth while to do so, but perhaps it may be as well to state,
that whatever may be his opinion of the truths of the conclusions arrived at by the council,
no impartial reader can fail to recognize the profound learning509 of the assembly, the sin-
gular acumen displayed in the arguments employed, and the remarkable freedom from what
Gibbon and many others would consider “superstition.” So radical is this that Gibbon would
have noticed it had he read the acts of the synod he is criticising (which we have good reason
for believing that he never did). There he would have found the Patriarch declaring that at
that time the venerable images worked no miracles, a statement that would be made by no
prelate of the Latin or Greek Church to-day, even in the light of the nineteenth century.
As I have noted in the previous pages my task is not that of a controversialist. To me
at present it is a matter of no concern whether the decision of the council is true or false. I
shall therefore strictly confine myself to two points: 1. That the Council was Ecumenical.
2. What its decision was; explaining the technical meaning of the Greek words employed
during this controversy and finally incorporated in the decree.
1. This Council was certainly Ecumenical.
507 Who was possibly at least not the president, vide Michaud, Sept. Conc. Œuméniques, p. 330.
508 Worship is “relative” or “absolute,” what Gibbon means by “direct” would be hard to say. How entirely
false the whole statement is, Gibbon himself would have recognized had he read the acts.
509 Dr. Neale complains that the acts display a painful lack of critical knowledge and that several spurious
passages are attributed to the Fathers. But I confess this does not seem to me either surprising or disgraceful.
The attributing of books, even in our critical days, to persons who were not their authors is not so uncommon
as to make us wonder such a thing might have occurred in such stormy times, when learning of this sort must
have suffered by the adversities of the Church and State, the Iconoclastic persecutions and the Moslem incursions.
Introduction.
984
Introduction.