That Origen was condemned by name in the Eleventh Canon
of this council there seems no possible reason to doubt. I have
given in connexion with that canon a full discussion of the evidence
upon which our present text rests. But there arises a further
question, to wit, Did the Fifth Synod examine the case of Origen and
finally adopt the XV. Anathemas against him which are usually found
assigned to it? It would seem that with the evidence now in our
possession it would be the height of rashness to give a dogmatic answer
to this question. Scholars of the highest repute have taken, and
do take to-day, the opposite sides of the case, and each defends his
own side with marked learning and ability. To my mind the chief
difficulty in supposing these anathematisms to have been adopted by the
Fifth Ecumenical is that nothing whatever is said about Origen in the
call of the council, nor in any of the letters written in connexion
with it; all of which would seem unnatural had there been a long
discussion upon the matter, and had such an important dogmatic
definition been adopted as the XV. Anathemas, and yet on the other hand
there is a vast amount of literature subsequent in date to the council
which distinctly attributes a detailed and careful examination of the
teaching of Origen and a formal condemnation of him and of it to this
council.