LETTER I.
TO MR. GILLESPIE. IN ANSWER TO OBJECTIONS.
Northampton, Sept. 4, 1747.
Rev. And Dear Sir,
I received your letter of Nov. 24, 1746, though very long after it was written. I thank
you for it, and for your offering me a correspondence with you. Such an offer I shall gladly
embrace, and esteem it a great privilege, more especially from the character I have received
of you from Mr. Abercrombie, who I perceive was intimately acquainted with you.
As to the objections you make against some things contained in my late book on Religious
Affections, I am sorry you did not read the book through, before you made them; if you had,
perhaps the difficulties would not have appeared quite so great. As to what is contained in
the 74th and 75th pages, I suppose there is not the least difference of opinion between you
and me, unless it be concerning the signification and propriety of expressions. I am fully of
your mind, and always was without the least doubt of it; “That every one, both saint and
sinner, is indispensably bound, at all seasons, by the divine authority, to believe instantly
on the Lord Jesus, and that the command of the Lord, 1 John iii. 23. that we should believe
on the name of his Son Jesus Christ, as it is a prescription of the moral law, no less binds
the sinner to immediate performance, than the commandment not to kill, to keep the Sab-
bath-day, or any other duty, as to the present performance of which, in way of duty, all agree
the sinner is bound; and that men are bound to trust the divine faithfulness, be their case
with respect to light and darkness, sight, &c. what it will; and that no situation they can be
in, looses them from obligation to glorify the Lord at all seasons, and expecting the fulfilment
of his words; and that the sinner that is without spiritual light or sight is bound to believe,
and that it is a duty at that very time incumbent on him to believe.” But I conceive that there
is a great deal of difference between these two things, viz. its being a man’s duty that is
without spiritual light or sight to believe, and its being his duty to believe without spiritual
light or sight, or to believe while he yet remains without spiritual light or sight. Just the same
difference that is between these two things, viz. its being his duty that has no faith to believe,
and its being his duty to believe without faith, or to believe without believing. I trust there
is none will assert the latter, because of the contradiction that it implies. As it is not proper
337
to say, it is a man’s duty to believe without faith, because it implies a contradiction, so I
think it equally improper to say it is a man’s duty to believe without these things that are
essentially implied in faith, because that also implies a contradiction. But a spiritual sight
of Christ or knowledge of Christ is essentially implied in the very nature and notion of faith,
and therefore it is absurd to talk of believing on Christ without spiritual light or sight. It is
the duty of a man that is without these things that essentially belong to faith, to believe, and
it is the duty of a man that is without these things that essentially belong to love, to love
God; because it is an indispensable obligation that lies on all men at all times, and in all
LETTER I. To Mr. Gillespie, in answer to objections.
1482
LETTER I. To Mr. Gillespie, in answer to objections.