The
testimony of antiquity,—both orthodox and heretical,—to the
authenticity of John’s Gospel is universal, with the exception of
a single unimportant sect of the second century, the Alogi, who denied
the Johannine authorship on account of the Logos doctrine, which they
rejected, and very absurdly ascribed the Gospel to the Gnostic
Cerinthus; though its absolute opposition to Cerinthus’ views is
so apparent that Irenæus (III. 11. 1) even supposed John to have
written the Gospel against Cerinthus. The writings of the second
century are full of the spirit of John’s Gospel, and exhibit
frequent parallels in language too close to be mistaken; while from the
last quarter of the second century on it is universally and expressly
ascribed to John (Theophilus of Antioch and the Muratorian Fragment
being the first to name him as its author). The Church never
entertained a doubt of its authenticity until the end of the
seventeenth century, when it was first questioned by the English
Deists; but its genuineness was vindicated, and only scattering and
occasional attacks were made upon it until the rise of the
Tübingen school, since which time its authenticity has been one of
the most fiercely contested points in apostolic history. Its opponents
have been obliged gradually to throw back the date of its origin, until
now no sensible critic thinks of assigning it to a time later than the
early part of the second century, which is a great gain over the
position of Baur and his immediate followers, who threw it into the
latter half of the century. See Schaff’s Ch. Hist. I.
701–724 for a full defense of its authenticity and a
comprehensive account of the controversy; also p. 406–411 for the
literature of the subject. For the most complete summary of the
external evidence, see Ezra Abbott’s The Authorship of the
Fourth Gospel, 1880. Among recent works, compare Weiss’
Leben Jesu, I. 84–124, and his N. T. Einleitung,
586–620, for a defense of the Gospel, and upon the other side
Holtzmann’s Einleitung, 413–460, and
Weizsäcker’s Apost. Zeitalter, p.
531–558.