who were absent. They would have acted unjustly to these innocent men, had they even re-
solved to pardon them, when they were not proved guilty, and had not confessed the guilt,
but were actually not present at all. For the guilt of a man is established beyond question
when he accepts a pardon. How much more outrageous and blind were they who thought
that they had power to condemn for crimes which, as unknown, they could not even have
forgiven! In the former case, crimes that were known were remitted to the divine arbitration,
lest others should be inquired into; in the latter case, crimes that were not known were made
ground of condemnation, that those which were known might be concealed. But it will be
said, the crime of Cæcilianus and the others was known. Even if I were to admit this, the
fact of their absence ought to have protected them from such a sentence. For they were not
chargeable with deserting a tribunal before which they had never stood; nor was the Church
so exclusively represented in these African bishops, that in refusing to appear before them
they could be supposed to decline all ecclesiastical jurisdiction. For there remained thousands
of bishops in countries beyond the sea, before whom it was manifest that those who seemed
to distrust their peers in Africa and Numidia could be tried. Have you forgotten what
Scripture commands: “Blame no one before you have examined him; and when you have
examined him, let your correction be just”?1634 If, then, the Holy Spirit has forbidden us to
blame or correct any one before we have questioned him, how much greater is the crime of
not merely blaming or correcting, but actually condemning men who, being absent, could
not be examined as to the charges brought against them!
12. Moreover, as to the assertion of these judges, that though the parties accused were
absent, having not fled from trial, but always avowed their distrust of that faction, and de-
clined to appear before them, the crimes for which they condemned them were well known;
I ask, my brethren, how did they know them? You reply, We cannot tell, since the evidence
is not stated in the public Acts. But I will tell you how they knew them. Observe carefully
280
the case of Felix of Aptunga, and first read how much more vehement they were against
him; for they had just the same grounds for their knowledge in the case of the others as in
his, who was afterwards proved most completely innocent by a thorough and severe invest-
igation. How much greater the justice and safety and readiness with which we are warranted
in believing the innocence of the others whose indictment was less serious, and their con-
demnation less severe, seeing that the man against whom they raged much more furiously
has been proved innocent!
Chap. IV.
13. Some one may perhaps make an objection which, though it was disapproved by you
when it was brought forward, I must not pass over, for it has been made by others, viz.: It
was not meet that a bishop should be acquitted by trial before a proconsul: as if the bishop
1634 Ecclus. xi. 7.
636
To Glorius, Eleusius, etc.