We now reach the famous Eutychian controversy, on
which Leo’s chief claim to our thanks and praise rests: for
to his action in it the Church owes the final and complete definition
of the cardinal doctrine of the Incarnation. The heresy of
Eutyches, as was the case with so many other heresies, sprang from the
reaction against a counter heresy. Most of the controversies
which have again and again imperilled the cause of Christianity, have
been due to human frailty, which has been unable to keep the proportion
of the Faith. Over-statement on the one side leads to
over-statement on the other, and thus the golden mean is lost sight
of. Eutyches, an archimandrite (or head of a monastery) at
Constantinople, had distinguished himself for zeal during the years 428
to 431 in combating the heresy of Nestorius, who had denied the perfect
union of the Godhead and the Manhood in the one Person, Christ
Jesus. He had objected to the Virgin being called
Theotokos (God-bearing), and said that Christotokos
(Christ-bearing) would be more correct. This position, as
involving two persons as well as two natures in our Lord, was condemned by the 3rd General Council, which met
at Ephesus in 431, S. Cyril being its chief opponent. But
Eutyches in his eagerness to proclaim the Unity of the Person of Christ
fell into the opposite extreme, and asserted that though the two
natures of Christ were originally distinct, yet after the union they
became but one nature, the human being changed into the Divine.
Eutyches appears to have been a highly virtuous person, but possessed
of a dull, narrow mind, unfit for the subtleties of theological
discussion, and therefore unable to grasp the conception of two Natures
in one Person: and nothing worse than stupidity and obstinacy is
brought against him by his stern but clear-headed opponent
Leo.