or longer Greek recension, as it is called, consists of fifteen epistles, which were first published in the fifteenth
and sixteenth centuries. Of these fifteen, eight are clearly spurious, and seven are at least largely interpolated.
The genuineness of the former and the integrity of the latter now find no defenders among scholars. The second,
or shorter Greek recension, contains seven of the fifteen epistles of the longer recension, in a much shorter form.
Their titles are the same that are given by Eusebius in this chapter. They were first discovered and published in
the seventeenth century. The third, or Syriac recension, contains three of these seven epistles (to Polycarp, to
the Ephesians, and to the Romans), in a still shorter form, and was discovered in the present century. Since its
discovery, opinions have been divided between it and the shorter Greek recension; but the defense of the genu-
ineness of the latter by Zahn and Lightfoot may be regarded as finally settling the matter, and establishing the
originality of the shorter Greek recension as over against that represented by the Syriac version. The former,
therefore, alone comes into consideration in discussing the genuineness of the Ignatian epistles. Their genuineness
is still stoutly denied by some; but the evidence in their favor, external and internal, is too strong to be set aside;
and since the appearance of Lightfoot’s great work, candid scholars almost unanimously admit that the question
is settled, and their genuineness triumphantly established. The great difficulties which have stood in the way of
the acceptance of the epistles are, first and chiefly, the highly developed form of church government which they
reveal; and secondly, the attacks upon heresy contained in them. Both of these characteristics seem to necessitate
a date later than the reign of Trajan, the traditional time of Ignatius’ martyrdom. Harnack regards these two
difficulties as very serious, if not absolutely fatal to the supposition that the epistles were written during the
reign of Trajan; but in a very keen tract, entitled Die Zeit des Ignatius (Leipzig, 1878), he has endeavored to show
that the common tradition that Ignatius suffered martyrdom under Trajan is worthless, and he therefore brings
the martyrdom down into the reign of Hadrian, and thus does away with most of the internal difficulties which
beset the acceptance of the epistles. Whether or not Harnack’s explanation of Eusebius’ chronology of the Anti-
ochian bishops be accepted as correct (and the number of its adherents is not great), he has, at least, shown that
the tradition that Ignatius suffered martyrdom under Trajan is not as strong as it has been commonly supposed
to be, and that it is possible to question seriously its reliability. Lightfoot, who discusses Harnack’s theory at
considerable length (II. p. 450–469), rejects it, and maintains that Ignatius died sometime during the reign of
Trajan, though, with Zahn and Harnack, he gives up the traditional date of 107 a.d., which is found in the
Chronicle of Eusebius, and has been very commonly accepted as reliable. Lightfoot, however, remarks that the
genuineness of the epistles is much more certain than the chronology of Ignatius, and that, therefore, if it is a
question between the rejection of the epistles and the relegation of Ignatius’ death to the reign of Hadrian (which
he, however, denies), the latter alternative must be chosen without hesitation. A final decision upon this knotty
point has not yet been, and perhaps never will be, reached; but Harnack’s theory that the epistles were written
during the reign of Hadrian deserves even more careful consideration than it has yet received. Granting the
genuineness of the Ignatian epistles, we are still in possession of no great amount of information in regard to
his life. We know from them only that he was bishop of the church of Antioch in Syria, and had been condemned
to martyrdom, and that he was, at the time of their composition, on his way to Rome to suffer death in the arena.
His character and opinions, however, are very clearly exhibited in his writings. To quote from Schaff, “Ignatius
stands out in history as the ideal of a Catholic martyr, and as the earliest advocate of the hierarchical principle
in both its good and its evil points. As a writer, he is remarkable for originality, freshness, and force of ideas,
361
Ignatius and His Epistles.