29. But, observe, say they, God was always a
Maker, nor is the power of framing adventitious to Him; does it follow
then, that, because He is the Framer of all, therefore His works also
are eternal, and is it wicked to say of them too, that they were not
before origination? Senseless are these Arians; for what likeness is
there between Son and work, that they should parallel a father’s
with a maker’s function? How is it that, with that difference
between offspring and work, which has been shewn, they remain so
ill-instructed? Let it be repeated then, that a work is external to the
nature, but a son is the proper offspring of the essence; it follows
that a work need not have been always, for the workman frames it when
he will; but an offspring is not subject to will, but is proper to the
essence Vid.
Orat. iii. §59, &c.. And a man may be and may be called
Maker, though the works are not as yet; but father he cannot be called,
nor can he be, unless a son exist. And if they curiously inquire why
God, though always with the power to make, does not always make (though
this also be the presumption of madmen, for ‘who hath known the
mind of the Lord, or who hath been His Counsellor?’ or how
‘shall the thing formed say to’ the potter, ‘why
didst thou make me thus Rom. xi. 34; ib. ix.
20.?’ however,
not to leave even a weak argument unnoticed), they must be told, that
although God always had the power to make, yet the things originated
had not the power of being eternal Athan.’s argument is as follows: that, as it is of the
essence of a son to be ‘connatural’ with the father, so is
it of the essence of a creature to be of ‘nothing,’
ἐξ οὐκ
ὄντων; therefore,
while it was not impossible ‘from the nature of the
case,’ for Almighty God to be always Father, it was
impossible for the same reason that He should be always a Creator. vid.
infr. §58: where he takes, ‘They shall perish,’ in the
Psalm, not as a fact but as the definition of the nature of a
creature. Also ii. §1, where he says, ‘It is proper to
creatures and works to have said of them, ἐξ
οὐκ ὄντων and οὐκ
ἦν πρὶν
γεννηθῇ.’ vid. Cyril. Thesaur. 9. p. 67. Dial. ii. p.
460. on the question of being a Creator in posse, vid. supra,
Ep. Eus. 11 note 3.. For they are
out of nothing, and therefore were not before their origination; but
things which were not before their origination, how could these coexist
with the ever-existing God? Wherefore God, looking to what was good for
them, then made them all when He saw that, when originated, they were
able to abide. And as, though He was able, even from the beginning in
the time of Adam, or Noah, or Moses, to send His own Word, yet He sent
Him not until the consummation of the ages (for this He saw to be good
for the whole creation), so also things originated did He make when He
would, and as was good for them. But the Son, not being a work, but proper to the Father’s
offspring, always is; for, whereas the Father always is, so what is
proper to His essence must always be; and this is His Word and His
Wisdom. And that creatures should not be in existence, does not
disparage the Maker; for He hath the power of framing them, when He
wills; but for the offspring not to be ever with the Father, is a
disparagement of the perfection of His essence. Wherefore His works
were framed, when He would, through His Word; but the Son is ever the
proper offspring of the Father’s essence.