friendship towards the man they speak to, and yet not think that he has any love in his heart
to him, yea, and know at the same time that he had a reigning enmity against him; and it
was known that this was the established principle of the people; would not these words,
whatever their proper signification was, entirely cease to be any profession or testimony of
friendship to his neighbour? To be sure, there could be no visibility of it to the eye of reason.
Thus it is evident, that those who are admitted into the church on the principles that I
oppose, are not professing saints, nor visible saints; because that thing which alone is truly
saintship, is not what they profess, or pretend, or have any visibility of, to the eye of a
christian judgment. Or if they in fact be visible and professing saints, yet they are not admitted
as such; no profession of true saintship, nor any manner of visibility of it, has any thing to
do in the affair.
There is one way to evade these things, which has been taken by some. They plead, Al-
though it be true, that the Scripture represents the members of the visible church of Christ
as professors of godliness; and they are abundantly called by the name of saints in Scripture,
undoubtedly because they were saints by profession, and in visibility, and the acceptance of
others, yet this is not with any reference to saving holiness, but to quite another sort of
saintship, viz. moral sincerity; and that this is the real saintship, discipleship, and godliness,
which is professed, and visible in them, and with regard to which, as having an appearance
of it to the eye of reason, they have the name of saints, disciples, &c. in Scripture.—It must
be noted, that in this objection the visibility is supposed to be of real saintship, discipleship,
and godliness, but only another sort of real godliness, than that which belongs to those who
shall finally be owned by Christ as his people, at the day of judgment.
To which I answer, This is a mere evasion; the only one, that ever I saw or heard of; and
I think the only one possible. For it is certain, they are not professors of sanctifying grace,
or true saintship: the principle proceeded on being, that they need make no pretence to that;
nor has any visibility of saving holiness any thing to do in the affair. If then they have any
holiness at all, it must be of another sort. And if this evasion fails, all fails, and the whole
matter in debate must be given up. Therefore I desire that this matter may be impartially
considered and examined to the very bottom; and that it may be thoroughly inquired,
whether this distinction of these two sorts of real Christianity, godliness, and holiness, is a
distinction of which Christ in his word is the author; or whether it be a human invention
of something which the New Testament knows nothing of, devised to serve and maintain
an hypotheses.—And here I desire that the following things may be observed:
1. According to this hypothesis, the words saints, disciples, and Christians, are used four
ways in the New Testament, as applies to four sorts of persons. (1.) To those that in truth
and reality are the heirs of eternal life, and that shall judge the world, or have indeed that
saintship which is saving. (2.) To those who profess this, and pretend to and make a fair
show of a supreme regard to Christ, and to renounce the world for his sake, but have not
1761
SECTION I. Church members should be visible saints.