(C) All the above were entirely superseded by the
great (20) 1698 Paris Benedictine Edition by Bernard de Montfaucon, aided, for part of vol. 1, by Jacques Loppin,
3 volumes fol. (i.e. vol. 1, parts 1 and 2, ‘genuina,’ vol.
2 ‘dubia et spuria’), with a new
Latin Version and ample prolegomena, &c. Montfaucon took over,
apparently without revision, the critical data of Felckmann (including
his mistake as to the age of the Basel ms. but
collated very many fresh mss. (principally
Parisian, full particulars in Migne xxvi. pp. 1449, sqq.), and
for the first time put the text on a fairly satisfactory footing. The
Works of Athanasius were freshly arranged with an attempt at
chronological order, and a ‘Monitum’ or short introduction
prefixed to each. Critical, and a few explanatory, notes throughout;
also an ‘onomasticon’ or glossary. This splendid edition
was far more complete than its predecessors, and beautifully printed.
After its completion, Montfaucon discovered fresh material, most of
which he published in vol. 2 of his ‘Collectio
Nova Patrum,’ Paris, 1706, with some further supplementary
matter to his Prolegomena, partly in reply to Tillemont upon various
critical questions; small additions in his Biblioth.
Coisliniana, 1715. (The letters to Lucifer, included in
Montfaucon’s edition, had already seen the light in vol. iv. of
the Bibliotheca Maxima Patrum (Lyons, 1677, Greek fathers in Latin
only), and the two notes to Orsisius were taken from the life of
Pachomius in the Acta SS. for May.)