54. Can, then, anything be made, some one will say, without God’s will? We3775 must
consider carefully, and examine with no little pains, lest, while we think that we are honouring
God3776 by such a question, we fall into the opposite sin, doing despite to His supreme
majesty. In what way, you ask, on what ground? Because, if all things are brought about by
His will, and nothing in the world can either succeed or fail contrary to His pleasure, it follows
of necessity that it should be understood that3777 all evils, too, arise by His will. But if, on
the contrary, we chose to say that He is privy to and produces no evil, not referring to Him
the causes of very wicked deeds, the worst things will begin to seem to be done either against
His will, or, a monstrous thing to say, while He knows it not, but is ignorant and unaware
of them. But, again, if we choose to say that there are no evils, as we find some have believed
and held, all races will cry out against us and all nations together, showing us their sufferings,
and the various kinds of dangers with which the human race is every moment3778 distressed
and afflicted. Then they will ask of us, Why, if there are no evils, do you refrain from certain
deeds and actions? Why do you not do all that eager lust has required or demanded? Why,
finally, do you establish punishments by terrible laws for the guilty? For what more mon-
strous3779 act of folly can be found than to assert that there are no evils, and at the same
time to kill and condemn the erring as though they were evil?3780
3775 The ms. and first three edd., read vobis—“you,” corrected nobis, as above, by Ursinus.
3776 So the ms.; but most edd., following the Brussels transcript, read dominum—“Lord.”
3777 Utis omitted in the ms., first four edd., and Hild.
3778 So LB., reading p-uncta for the ms. c-uncta.
3779 So the ms., Hild., and Oehler, reading imman-ior; LB., from the margin of Ursinus, major—“greater;”
the rest, inanior—“more foolish.”
3780 The difficulty felt by Arnobius as to the origin of evil perplexed others also; and, as Elmenhorst has ob-
served, some of the Fathers attempted to get rid of it by a distinction between the evil of guilt and of punish-
ment,—God being author of the latter, the devil of the former (Tertullian, adv. Marcionem, ii. 14). It would have
been simpler and truer to have distinguished deeds, which can be done only if God will, from wickedness, which
is in the sinful purpose of man’s heart.
Chapter LIV.
1058
Chapter LIV.