Part
III.—Apocryphal Apocalypses.
This portion of the volume, extending from page 565 to
page 598, consists of seven documents, four of which are called
Apocalypses by their authors. Of these, the Greek text of the
first three is edited for the first time; the fourth, the Apocalypse of
John, has appeared before. The fifth, The Falling Asleep of Mary,
appears for the first time in its Greek form, and in the first Latin
recension of it.
The
mss.
of these
documents are characterized by extreme variety of readings; and in some
of them, especially the earlier portion of the Apocalypse of Esdras,
the text is in a very corrupt state.
I.
The Apocalypse of
Moses
.—This document belongs to the Apocrypha of the Old
Testament rather than that of the New. We have been unable to
find in it any reference to any Christian writing. In its form,
too, it appears to be a portion of some larger work. Parts of it
at least are of an ancient date, as it is very likely from this source
that the writer of the Gospel of Nicodemus took the celebrated legend
of the Tree of Life and the Oil of Mercy. An account of this
legend will be found in Cowper’s
Apocryphal Gospels
,
xcix.–cii.; in Maury,
Croyances et
Légendes de l’Antiquité
, p. 294; in
Renan’s commentary to the Syriac text of the Penitence of Adam,
edited and translated by Renan in the
Journal Asiatique
for
1853. There appeared a poetical rendering of the legend in
Blackwood’s Magazine
ten or twelve years ago.
Tischendorf’s text is made from four
mss.
: A, a Venice
ms.
of the thirteenth century; B and C, Vienna
mss.
of the thirteenth and twelfth centuries respectively;
and D, a Milan
ms.
of about the eleventh
century.
II.
The Apocalypse of
Esdras
.—This book is a weak imitation of the apocryphal
fourth book of Esdras. Thilo, in his prolegomena to the Acts of
Thomas, p. lxxxii., mentions it, and doubts whether it be the fourth
book of Esdras or not. Portions of it were published by Dr. Hase
of the Paris Library, and it was then seen that it was a different
production. The
ms.
is of about the
fifteenth century, and in the earlier portions very difficult to
read.
III.
The Apocalypse of
Paul
.—There are two apocryphal books bearing the name of Paul
mentioned by ancient writers: The Ascension of Paul, adopted by
the Cainites and the Gnostics; and the Apocalypse of Paul, spoken of by
Augustine and Sozomen. There seems to be no doubt that the
present text, discovered by Tischendorf in 1843, and published by him
in 1866, is the book mentioned by Augustine and Sozomen. It is
referred to by numerous authorities, one of whom, however, ascribes it
to the heretic Paul of Samosata, the founder of the sect of the
Paulicians.
There appear to be versions of it in Coptic,
Syriac, and Arabic. One of the Syriac versions, from an Urumiyeh
ms.
, was translated into English by an American
missionary in 1864. This translation, or the greater portion of
it, is printed by Tischendorf along with his edition of the
text.
Tischendorf,
upon what seems to be pretty good evidence, ascribes it to the year
380. It is from a Milan
ms.
of not
earlier than the fifteenth century. There is another
ms.
two centuries older; but they both seem to be copied
from the same original. The Syriac seems to be later than the
Greek, and, according to Eastern fashion, fuller in details.
IV.
The Apocalypse of John
.—In
the scholia to the Grammar of Dionysius the Thracian, ascribed to the
ninth century, immediately after the ascription of the Apocalypse of
Paul to Paul of Samosata, there occurs the following statement:
‘And there is another called the Apocalypse of John the
Theologian. We do not speak of that in the island of Patmos, God
forbid, for it is most true; but of a supposititious and spurious
one.’ This is the oldest reference to this
Apocalypse. Asseman says he found the book in Arabic in three
mss.
The document was first edited by Birch in 1804,
from a Vatican
ms.
, collated with a Vienna
ms.
For his edition Tischendorf collated
other five
mss.
, two of Paris, three of Vienna,
of from the fourteenth to the sixteenth century.
Of other Apocalypses, Tischendorf in his
Prolegomena
gives an abstract of the Apocalypse of Peter, the
Apocalypse of Bartholomew, the Apocalypse of Mary, and the Apocalypse
of Daniel. The Apocalypse of Peter professes to be written by
Clement. There is an Arabic
ms.
of it in
the Bodleian Library. It is called the Perfect Book, or the Book
of Perfection, and consists of eighty-nine chapters, comprising a
history of the world as revealed to Peter, from the foundation of the
world to the appearing of Antichrist.
The Apocalypse of Bartholomew, from a
ms.
in the Paris Library, was edited and translated by
Dulaurier in 1835. The translation appears in Tischendorf’s
Prolegomena
.
The Apocalypse of Mary, containing her descent to
the lower world, appears in several Greek
mss.
It is of a late date, the work of some monk of
the middle ages.
The Apocalypse of Daniel, otherwise called the
Revelation of the Prophet Daniel about the consummation of the world,
is also of a late date. About the half of the Greek text is given
in the
Prolegomena
. We have not thought it necessary to
translate it.
V., VI., VII.
The Assumption of
Mary
.—It is somewhat strange that the Greek text of this
book, which has been translated into several languages both of the East
and the West, is edited by Tischendorf for the first time. He
assigns it to a date not later than the fourth century. A book
under this title is condemned in the decree of Gelasius. The
author of the Second Latin Form (see p. 595, note), writing under the
name of Melito, ascribes the authorship of a treatise on the same
subject to Leucius. This, however, cannot be the book so ascribed
to Leucius, as Pseudo-Melito affirms that his book, which is in
substance the same as the Greek text, was written to condemn
Leucius’ heresies.
There are translations or recensions of our text
in Syriac, Sahidic, and Arabic. The Syriac was edited and
translated by Wright in 1865, in his
Contributions to the Apocryphal
Literature of the New Testament
. Another recension of it was
published in the
Journal of Sacred Literature
for January and
April, 1864. An Arabic version of it, resembling more the Syriac
than the Greek or Latin, was edited and translated by Enger in
1854. The Sahidic recension, published and translated by Zoega
and Dulaurier, is considerably different from our present texts.
The numerous Latin recensions also differ considerably from each other,
as will be seen from a comparison of the First Latin Form with the
Second. They are all, however, from the same source, and that
probably the Greek text which we have translated. The Greek
texts, again, exhibit considerable variations, especially in the latter
portions.
In the end of the seventh century, John Archbishop
of Thessalonica wrote a discourse on the falling asleep of Mary, mainly
derived from the book of Pseudo-John; and in some
mss.
this treatise of John of Thessalonica is ascribed to
John the Apostle. Epiphanius, however, makes distinctive mention
of both treatises.
For his
edition of the Greek text, Tischendorf made use of five
mss.
, the oldest of the eleventh century.
The First Latin Form is edited from three Italian
mss.
, the oldest of the thirteenth
century.
The Second Latin Form, which has been previously
published elsewhere, is from a Venetian
ms.
of
the fourteenth century.
We have now concluded our notices, compiled
chiefly from Tischendorf’s
Prolegomena
, of the Apocryphal
Literature of the New Testament.
While these documents are of considerable interest and
value, as giving evidence of a widespread feeling in early times of the
importance of the events which form the basis of our belief, and as
affording us curious glimpses of the state of the Christian conscience,
and of modes of Christian thought, in the first centuries of our era,
the predominant impression which they leave on our minds is a profound
sense of the immeasurable superiority, the unapproachable simplicity
and majesty, of the Canonical Writings.
St. Andrews
, 26
th
March
, 1870.