any one in our day to feign compliance with these Jewish observances, although you believe
that the apostles did this.
18. Accordingly, as you in opposing me affirm, and, to quote your own words, “though
the world were to protest against it, boldly declare that the Jewish ceremonies are to Chris-
tians both hurtful and fatal, and that whoever observes them, whether he was originally Jew
or Gentile, is on his way to the pit of perdition,”2029 I entirely indorse that statement, and
add to it, “Whoever observes these ceremonies, whether he was originally Jew or Gentile,
is on his way to the pit of perdition, not only if he is sincerely observing them, but also if he
is observing them with dissimulation.” What more do you ask? But as you draw a distinction
between the dissimulation which you hold to have been practised by the apostles, and the
rule of conduct befitting the present time, I do the same between the course which Paul, as
I think, sincerely followed in all these examples then, and the matter of observing in our
day these Jewish ceremonies, although it were done, as by him, without any dissimulation,
since it was then to be approved, but is now to be abhorred. Thus, although we read that
“the law and the prophets were until John,”2030 and that “therefore the Jews sought the
more to kill Him, because He not only had broken the Sabbath, but said also that God was
His Father, making Himself equal with God,”2031 and that “we have received grace for grace
for the law was given by Moses, but grace and truth came by Jesus Christ;”2032 and although
it was promised by Jeremiah that God would make a new covenant with the house of Judah,
not according to the covenant which He made with their fathers;2033 nevertheless I do not
think that the Circumcision of our Lord by His parents was an act of dissimulation. If any
one object that He did not forbid this because He was but an infant, I go on to say that I do
not think that it was with intention to deceive that He said to the leper, “Offer for thy
356
cleansing those things which Moses commanded for a testimony unto them,”2034—thereby
adding His own precept to the authority of the law of Moses regarding that ceremonial usage.
Nor was there dissimulation in His going up to the feast,2035 as there was also no desire to
be seen of men; for He went up, not openly, but secretly.
19. But the words of the apostle himself may be quoted against me: “Behold, I Paul say
unto you, that if ye be circumcised, Christ shall profit you nothing.”2036 It follows from this
2029 See Letter LXXV. sec. 14, pp. 338, 339.
2030 Luke xvi. 16.
2031 John v. 18.
2032 John i. 16, 17.
2033 Jer. xxxi. 31.
2034 Mark i. 44.
2035 John vii. 10.
2036 Gal. v. 2.
795
To Jerome