the moisture in the form of drops (and the drop is called a tear), so I would have you think
that when the pores, as a result of the contrary condition, are unusually widened, some air
is drawn in through them into the interior, and thence again expelled by nature through
the passage of the mouth, while all the viscera (and especially, as they say, the liver) join in
expelling this air by a certain agitation and throbbing motion; whence it comes that nature,
contriving to give facility for the exit of the air, widens the passage of the mouth, extending
the cheeks on either side round about the breath; and the result is called laughter.
6. We must not, then, on this account ascribe the ruling principle any more to the liver
than we must think, because of the heated state of the blood about the heart in wrathful
dispositions, that the seat of the mind is in the heart; but we must refer these matters to the
character of our bodily organization, and consider that the mind is equally in contact with
each of the parts according to a kind of combination which is indescribable.
7. Even if any should allege to us on this point the Scripture which claims the ruling
principle for the heart, we shall not receive the statement without examination; for he who
makes mention of the heart speaks also of the reins, when he says, “God trieth the hearts
and reins”1629; so that they must either confine the intellectual principle to the two combined
or to neither.
8. And although I am aware that the intellectual energies are blunted, or even made al-
together ineffective in a certain condition of the body, I do not hold this a sufficient evidence
for limiting the faculty of the mind by any particular place, so that it should be forced out
of its proper amount of free space by any inflammations that may arise in the neighbouring
parts of the body1630 (for such an opinion is a corporeal one, that when the receptacle is
already occupied by something placed in it, nothing else can find place there); for the intel-
ligible nature neither dwells in the empty spaces of bodies, nor is extruded by encroachments
of the flesh; but since the whole body is made like some musical instrument, just as it often
happens in the case of those who know how to play, but are unable, because the unfitness
of the instrument does not admit of their art, to show their skill (for that which is destroyed
by time, or broken by a fall, or rendered useless by rust or decay, is mute and inefficient,
even if it be breathed upon by one who may be an excellent artist in flute-playing); so too
the mind, passing over the whole instrument, and touching each of the parts in a mode
corresponding to its intellectual activities, according to its nature, produces its proper effect
on those parts which are in a natural condition, but remains inoperative and ineffective
upon those which are unable to admit the movement of its art; for the mind is somehow
naturally adapted to be in close relation with that which is in a natural condition, but to be
alien from that which is removed from nature.
1629 Ps. vii. 10.
1630 The inflammation causing swelling in the neighbouring parts, and so leaving no room for the mind.
737
An examination of the question where the ruling principle is to be considered…