thing of this nature. Certainly if we are of the spirit of the apostle Paul, and have his discre-
tion, we shall not set up any such practice without it. He, for the sake of peace, conformed
in things wherein he was not particularly forbidden, to the Jews when among them; and so,
when among those that were without the law, he conformed to them wherein he might.—To
be sure, those go much beyond proper limits, who, coming from abroad, do immediately
of their own heads, in a strange place, set up such a new and uncommon practice among a
people.
In introducing any thing of this nature among a people, their minister especially ought
to be consulted, and his voice taken, as long as he is owned for their minister. Ministers are
pastors of worshipping societies, and their heads and guides in the affairs of public worship.
They are called in Scripture, “those that rule over them;” and their people are commanded
Heb. xiii. 17. “to obey them, because they watch for their souls, as those that must give ac-
count.” If it belongs to these shepherds and rulers to direct and guide the flock in any thing
at all, it belongs to them so to do in the circumstantials of their public worship.—Thus I
have taken particular notice of many of those things that have appeared to me to be amiss
in the management of our religious concerns relating to the present revival of religion, and
have taken liberty freely to express my thoughts upon them. Upon the whole it appears
manifest to me, that things have as yet never been set a-going in their right channel; if they
had, and means had been blessed in proportion as they have been now, this work would
have so prevailed, as before this time to have carried all before it, and have triumphed over
New England as its conquest.
The devil, in driving things to these extremes, besides the present hindrance of the work
of God, has, I believe, had in view a twofold mischief, in the issue of things; one, with respect
to those that are cold in religion, to carry things to such an extreme in order that people in
general, having their eyes opened by the great excess, might be tempted entirely to reject
the whole work, as being all nothing but delusion and distraction. And another, with respect
to those of God’s children who have been very warm and zealous out of the way, to sink
them down in unbelief and darkness. The time is coming, I doubt not, when the greater
part of them will be convinced of their errors; and then probably the devil will take advantage
to lead them into a dreadful wilderness, to puzzle and confound them about their own ex-
periences, and the experiences of others; and to make them to doubt of many things that
they ought not, and even to tempt them with atheistical thoughts. I believe, if all true
Christians over the land should now at once have their eyes opened fully to see all their errors,
it would seem for the present to damp religion. The dark thoughts that it would at first oc-
casion, and the inward doubts, difficulties, and conflicts that would rise in their souls, would
deaden their lively affections and joys, and would cause an appearance of a present decay
of religion. But yet it would do God’s saints great good in their latter end; it would fit them
for more spiritual and excellent experiences, more humble and heavenly love, and unmixed
1711
SECTION VI. Errors relative to singing.