22. If then God also wrought and compounded out
of materials, this indeed is a gentile thought, according to which God
is an artificer and not a Maker, but yet even in that case let the Word
work the materials, at the bidding and in the service of God προσταττόμενος
καὶ
ὑπουργῶν. It is not quite clear that Athan. accepts these words in his own
person, as has been assumed de Decr. 9. note 2, de Syn.
27 (3). Vid. de Decr. 7. and infr. 24. and 31, which, as
far as they go, are against the use of the word. Also S. Basil objects
to ὑποῦργος contr. Eunom. ii. 21. and S.
Cyril in Joan. p. 48. though S. Basil speaks of τὸν
προστάττοντα
κύριον. i. 46,
note 3. and S. Cyril of the Son’s ὑποταγή,
Thesaur. p. 255. Vid. ‘ministering, ὑπηρετοῦντα, to the Father of all.’ Just. Tryph. p. 72.
‘The Word become minister, ὑπηρέτης, of the Creator,’ Origen Hom. in Joan. p. 61. also
Constit. Ap. viii. 12. but Pseudo-Athan. objects to ὑπηρετῶν, de Comm. Essent. 30. and Athan. apparently, infr.
28. Again, ‘Whom did He order, præcepit?’ Iren.
Hær. iii. 8. n. 3. ‘The Father bids, ἐντέλλεται
(allusion to Ps. xxxiii. 9. vid. infr. 31), the
Word accomplishes.…He who commands, κελεύων, is the Father, He who obeys, ὑπακούων, the Son.…The Father willed, ἠθέλησεν, the Son did it.’ Hippol. contr. Noet. 14. on which
Fabricius’s note. S. Hilary speaks of the Son as ‘subditus
per obedientiæ obsequelam.’ de Syn. 51. Vid. below,
on §31. In note 8 there the principle is laid down for the use of
these expressions. [Supr. p. 87, note 2.]. But if He calls into existence things which existed not
by His proper Word, then the Word is not in the number of things
non-existing and called; or we have to seek another Word Cf.
Ep. Æg. 14. vid. also supr. p. 155. and Orat.
iii. 2. 64. Aug. in Joan. Tract. i. 11. Vid. a parallel argument
with reference to the Holy Spirit. Serap. i. 25. b., through whom He too was called; for by the
Word the things which were not have come to be. And if through Him He
creates and makes, He is not Himself of things created and made; but
rather He is the Word of the Creator God and is known from the
Father’s works which He Himself worketh, to be ‘in the
Father and the Father in Him,’ and ‘He that hath seen Him
hath seen the Father Vid. John xiv. 9, 10.,’ because the
Son’s Essence is proper to the Father, and He in all points like
Him τὴν κατὰ
πάντα
ὁμοιότητα: vid. parallel instances, de Syn. 26 (5) note 1,
which add, ὅμοιος
κατὰ πάντα, Orat. i. 40. κατὰ πάντα
καὶ ἐν πᾶσι, Ep. Æg. 17, c. τοῦ πατρὸς
ὅμοιος,
Orat. ii. 17. Orat. iii. 20, a. ‘not ὅμοιος, as the
Church preaches, but ὡς αὐτοὶ
θέλουσι᾽ (vid. p. 289, note 4), also de Syn. 53, note 9.. How then does He create through Him, unless
it be His Word and His Wisdom? and how can He be Word and Wisdom,
unless He be the proper offspring of His Essence As
Sonship is implied in ‘Image’ (supr. §2, note
2), so it is implied in ‘Word’ and ‘Wisdom.’
Orat. iv. 15. Orat. iii. 29 init. de Decr. 17. And
still more pointedly, Orat. iv. 24 fin. vid. also supr.
i. 28, note 5. And so ‘Image is implied in Sonship: ‘being
Son of God He must be like Him,’ supr. 17. And so
‘Image’ is implied in Word;’ ἐν
τῇ ἰδί& 139·
εἰκόνι, ἥτις
ἐστὶν ὁ
λόγος
αὐτοῦ, infr.
82, d. also 34, c. On the contrary, the very root of heretical error
was the denial that these titles implied each other, vid. supr.
27, de Decr. 17, 24, notes., and did not come to be, as others, out of
nothing? And whereas all things are from nothing, and are creatures,
and the Son, as they say, is one of the creatures too and of things
which once were not, how does He alone reveal the Father, and none else
but He know the Father? For could He, a work, possibly know the Father,
then must the Father be also known by all according to the proportion
of the measures of each: for all of them are works as He is. But if it
be impossible for things originate either to see or to know, for the
sight and the knowledge of Him surpasses all (since God Himself says,
‘No one shall see My face and live Vid. Ex. xxxiii. 20.’), yet the Son has declared, ‘No
one knoweth the Father, save the Son Matt. xi. 27.,’
therefore the Word is different from all things originate, in that He
alone knows and alone sees the Father, as He says, ‘Not that any
one hath seen the Father, save He that is from the Father,’ and
‘no one knoweth the Father save the Son John vi. 46, not to the
letter.,’ though Arius think otherwise. How
then did He alone know, except that He alone was proper to Him? and how
proper, if He were a creature, and not a true Son from Him? (For one
must not mind saying often the same thing for religion’s sake.)
Therefore it is irreligious to think that the Son is one of all things;
and blasphemous and unmeaning to call Him ‘a creature, but not as
one of the creatures, and a work, but not as one of the works, an
offspring, but not as one of the offsprings;’ for how not as one
of these, if, as they say, He was not before His generation Vid.
supr. 1. and Exc. B.? for it is proper to the creatures and works
not to be before their origination, and to subsist out of nothing, even
though they excel other creatures in glory; for this difference of one
with another will be found in all creatures, which appears in those
which are visible Greek
text dislocated..