If we enquire the reason why this Council tried to
change the order of rank of the great Sees, which had been established
in the sixth Nicene canon, we must first take into consideration that,
since the elevation of Constantinople to the Imperial residence, as New
Rome, the bishops as well as the Emperors naturally wished to see the
new imperial residence, New Rome, placed immediately after Old Rome in
ecclesiastical rank also; the rather, as with the Greeks it was the
rule for the ecclesiastical rank of a See to follow the civil rank of
the city. The Synod of Antioch in 341, in its ninth canon, had
plainly declared this, and subsequently the fourth General Council, in
its seventeenth canon, spoke in the same sense. But how these
principles were protested against on the side of Rome, we shall see
further on in the history of the fourth General Council. For the
present, it may suffice to add that the aversion to Alexandria which,
by favouring Maximus, had exercised such a disturbing influence on
Church affairs in Constantinople, may well have helped to effect the
elevation of the See of Constantinople over that of Alexandria.
Moreover, for many centuries Rome did not recognize this change of the
old ecclesiastical order. In the sixteenth session of the fourth
General Council, the Papal Legate,
Lucentius, expressly declared this. In like manner the Popes Leo
the Great and Gregory the Great pronounced against it; and though even
Gratian adopted this canon in his collection the Roman critics added
the following note: Canon hic ex iis est, quos Apostolica
Romana Sedes a principio et longo post tempore non recepit.
It was only when, after the conquest of Constantinople by the Latins, a
Latin patriarchate was founded there in 1204, that Pope Innocent III,
and the twelfth General Council, in 1215, allowed this patriarch the
first rank after the Roman; and the same recognition was expressly
awarded to the Greek Patriarch at the Florentine Union in 1439.