The
Muratorian Fragment expressly ascribes two epistles to John. Citations
from the second Epistle appear first in Irenæus, though he does
not distinguish it from the first. Clement of Alexandria (Strom.
II. 15) quotes from 1 John under the formula “John says in his
larger Epistle,” showing that he knew of a second. The lack of
citations from the second and third Epistles is easily explained by
their brevity and the minor importance of their doctrinal contents. The
second and third Epistles belong to the seven Antilegomena.
Origen cites the first Epistle often, the second and third never, and
of the latter he says “not all agree that they are genuine”
(quoted by Eusebius, VI. 25), and apparently he himself did not
consider them of apostolic origin (cf. Weiss’ Einleitung,
p. 87). Origen’s treatment of the Catholic Epistles was
implicitly followed by his pupil Dionysius and by succeeding
generations. Eusebius himself does not express his own judgment in the
matter, but simply records the state of tradition which was a mere
repetition of Origen’s position in regard to them. Jerome (de
vir. ill. 9 and 18) says that most writers ascribe them to the
presbyter John—an opinion which evidently arose upon the basis of
the author’s self-designation in 2 John 1, and 3 John 1, and some modern
critics (among them Reuss and Wieseler) have done the same. Eusebius
himself in the next chapter implies that such an opinion existed in his
day, though he does not express his own view on the matter. He placed
them, however, among the Antilegomena. (On the presbyter John,
see below chap. 39, note 4.) That the two epistles fell originally into
the class of Antilegomena was due doubtless to the peculiar
self-designation mentioned, which seemed to distinguish the author from
the apostle, and also to their private and doctrinally unimportant
character. But in spite of the slight external testimony to the
epistles the conclusion of Weiss seems correct, that “inasmuch as
the second and third clearly betray the same author, and inasmuch as
the second is related to the first in such a manner that they must
either be by the same author or the former be regarded as an entirely
aimless imitation of the latter, so everything favors the ascription of
them both to the author of the first, viz. to the apostle.”
(ibid. p. 469.)