CHAP. XV.] OF THE HOLY SPIRIT AS THE GIFT. 161
are, because that is the spirit of a man which is in him ; but
this Spirit is ours in another mode, viz. that in which we also
say, " Give us this day our bread." ^ Although certainly we
have received that spirit also, which is called the spirit of a
man. "For what hast thou," he says, " which thou didst not
receive?"^ But that is one thing, which we have received
that we might be ; another, that which we have received that
we might be holy. Whence it is also written of John, that
he " came in the spirit and power of Elias ;"^ and by the spirit
ofElias is meant theHoly Spirit, whom Elias received. And the
same thing is to be understood of Moses, when the Lord says
to him, ''And I will take of thy spirit, and will put it upon
them ; " * that is, I will give to them of the Holy Spirit, which
I have already given to thee. If, therefore, that also which is
given has him for a beginning bywhom it is given, since it has
received from, no other source that which proceeds from him
;
it must be admitted that the Father and the Son are a begin-
ning of the Holy Spirit, not two beginnings ; but as the Father
and Son are one God, and one Creator, and one Lord relatively
to the creature, so are they one beginning relatively to the
Holy Spirit. But the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit
is one beginning in respect to the creature, as also one Creator
and one God.
Chap, xv,—Whether the Holy Spirit was a gift "before as icell as afterHe
was given.
16. But it is asked further, whether, as the Son, by being
born, has not only this, that He is the Son, but absolutely
that He is ; and so also the Holy Spirit, by being given, has
not only this, that He is given, but absolutely that He is
—
whether therefore He was, before He was given, but was not
yet a gift ; or whether, for the very reason that God was about
to give Him, He was already a gift also before He was given.
But if He does not proceed unless when He is given, and
assuredly could not proceed before there was one to whom He
might be given ; how, in that case, was He in His very sub-
stance, if He is not unless because He is given ? just as the
Son, by being born, not only has this, that He is a Son, which
is said relatively, but absolutely His very substance, so that
» Matt. vi. 11. 2 1 Cor. iv. 7. ^ l^^j^^ ^ 17, 4 i^^j^. xi. 17.
DE TRIN. L