of the precept as well as the punisher of disobedience; that by showing His righteous anger
against transgression, He might provide a restraint for the time, and a warning for the future.
Nor does He ask questions from ignorance, but by His very inquiry declares His judgment.
Nor is He curious or timid, but excludes the transgressor from eternal life, which is the just
reward of obedience. Nor is He greedy for blood and fat; but by requiring from a carnal
people sacrifices, suited to their character, He by certain types prefigures the true sacrifice.
Nor is His jealousy an emotion of pale anxiety, but of quiet benevolence, in desire to keep
the soul, which owes chastity to the one true God, from being defiled and prostituted by
serving many false gods. Nor is He enraged with a passion similar to human anger, but is
angry, not in the sense of desiring vengeance, but in the peculiar sense of giving full effect
to the sentence of a righteous retribution. Nor does He destroy thousands of men for trifling
offenses, or for nothing, but manifests to the world the benefit to be obtained from fearing
Him, by the temporal death of those already mortal. Nor does He punish the righteous and
sinners indiscriminately, but chastises the righteous for their good, in order to perfect them,
and gives to sinners the punishment justly due to them. Thus, ye Manichæans, do your
suspicions lead you astray, when, by misunderstanding our Scriptures, or by hearing bad
interpreters, you form a mistaken judgment of Catholics. Hence you leave sound doctrine,
and turn to impious fables; and in your perversity and estrangement from the society of
saints, you reject the instruction of the New Testament, which, as we have shown, contains
280
statements similar to those which you condemn in the Old Testament. So we are obliged
to defend both Testaments against you as well as against the Pagans.
22. But supposing that there is some one so deluded by carnality as to worship not the
God whom we worship, who is one and true, but the fiction of your suspicions or your
slanders, whom you say we worship, is not even this god better than yours? Observe, I be-
seech you, what must be plain to the feeblest understanding; for here there is no need of
great perspicacity. I address all, wise and unwise. I appeal to the common sense and judg-
ment of all alike. Hear, consider, judge. Would it not have been better for your god to have
remained in darkness from eternity, than to have plunged the light coeternal with him and
cognate to him into darkness? Would it not have been better to have expressed admiration
in surprise at the appearance of a new light coming to scatter the darkness, than to have
been unable to baffle the assault of darkness except by the concession of his own light?
Unhappy if he did this in alarm, and cruel if there was no need of it. Surely it would have
been better to see light, made by himself, and to admire it as good, than to make the light
begotten by himself evil; better than that his own light should become hostile to himself in
repelling the forces of darkness. For this will be the accusation against those who will be
condemned for ever to the mass of darkness, that they suffered themselves to lose their
original brightness, and became the enemies of sacred light. If they did not know from
eternity that they would be thus condemned, they must have suffered the darkness of
477
Faustus states his objections to the morality of the law and the prophets,…