As it is impossible to treat the theological question
here, so too is it impossible to treat the historical question.
However I may remind the reader that Nestorius and his heresy were
defended by Theodore of Mopsuestia, and that he and Celestius were
declared by Pope Zosimus to be innocent in the year 417, a decision
which was entirely disregarded by the rest of the world, a Carthaginian
Synod subsequently anathematizing him. Finally the Pope retracted
his former decision, and in 418 anathematized him and his fellow, and
gave notice of this in his “epistola tractoria” to the
bishops. Eighteen Italian bishops, who had followed the Pope in
his former decision of a twelve month before, refused to change their
minds at his bidding now, and were accordingly deposed, among them
Julian of Eclanum. After this Pelagius and Celestius found a
fitting harbour of refuge with Nestorius of Constantinople, and so all
three were condemned together by the council of Ephesus, he that denied
the incarnation of the Word, and they twain that denied the necessity
of that incarnation and of the grace purchased thereby.