(20.) Whosoever, speaking of the Holy Ghost as
Paraclete, shall mean the Ingenerate God, be he anathema It
was an expedient of the later Macedonians to deny that the Holy Spirit
was God because it was not usual to call Him Ingenerate. They asked the
Catholics whether the Holy Spirit was Ingenerate, generate, or
created, for into these three they divided all things. vid.
Basil in Sabell. et Ar. Hom. xxiv. 6. But, as the Arians had
first made the alternative only between Ingenerate and
created, and Athan. de Decr. §28. shews that
generate is a third idea really distinct from one and the other,
so S. Greg. Naz. adds. processive, ἐκπορευτὸν, as an intermediate idea, contrasted with
Ingenerate, yet distinct from generate. Orat. xxxi. 8. In
other words, Ingenerate means, not only not generate, but
not from any origin. vid. August. de Trin. xv.
26..