Generally speaking, the evidence points to the
conclusion that the Church imposed no penalty on the layman. St.
Basil (Epist. clxxxviii. can. 12), says that a usurer may even
be admitted to orders, provided he gives his acquired wealth to the
poor and abstains for the future from the pursuit of gain (Migne,
Patrol. Græc. xxxii. 275). Gregory of Nyssa says that
usury, unlike theft, the desecration of tombs, and sacrilege
(ἱεροσυλία
), is allowed to pass unpunished, although among the things forbidden
by Scripture, nor is a candidate at ordination ever asked whether or no
he has been guilty of the practice (Migne, ib. xlv. 233).
A letter of Sidonius Apollinaris (Epist. vi. 24) relating an
experience of his friend Maximus, appears to imply that no blame
attached to lending money at the legal rate of interest, and that even
a bishop might be a creditor on those terms. We find also
Desideratus, bishop of Verdun, when applying for a loan to king
Theodebert, for the relief of his impoverished diocese, promising
repayment, “cum usuris legitimis,” an expression which
would seem to imply that in the Gallican church usury was recognised as
lawful under certain conditions (Greg. Tur. Hist. Franc. iii.
34). So again a letter (Epist. ix. 38) of Gregory the
Great seems to shew that he did not regard the payment of interest for
money advanced by one layman to another as unlawful. But on the
other hand, we find in what is known as archbishop Theodore’s
“Penitential” (circ. a.d.
690) what appears to be a general law on the subject, enjoining
“Sie quis usuras undecunque exegerit…tres annos in pane et
aqua” (c. xxv. 3); a penance again enjoined in the Penitential of
Egbert of York (c. ii. 30). In like manner, the legates, George
and Theophylact, in reporting their proceedings in England to pope
Adrian I. (a.d. 787), state that they have
prohibited “usurers,” and cite the authority of the
Psalmist and St. Augustine (Haddan and Stubbs, Conc. iii.
457). The councils of Mayence, Rheims, and Châlons, in the
year 813, and that of Aix in the year 816, seem to have laid down the
same prohibition as binding both on the clergy and the laity (Hardouin,
Conc. iv. 1011, 1020, 1033, 1100).