ence in his ability to defend them by fair means, that the thought of employing sophistry in
their defence never occurred to him. But, if he had felt the want of sound arguments, he
would not have employed it. His conscience was too enlightened, and his mind too sincere.
His aim, in all his investigations, was the discovery and the defence of truth. He valued his
positions, only because they were true; and he gave them up at once, when he found that
they were not supported by argument and evidence.
Another trait in his character, as a reasoner, is originality, or invention. Before his time,
the theological writers of each given class or party, had, with scarcely an exception, followed
on, one after another, in the same beaten path, and, whenever any one had deviated from
it, he had soon lost himself in the mazes of error. Mr. Edwards had a mind too creative to
be thus dependent on others. If the reader will examine carefully his controversial and other
theological works, and compare them with those of his predecessors on the same subjects;
he will find that his positions are new, that his definitions are new, that his plans are new,
that his arguments are new, that his conclusions are new, that his mode of reasoning and
his methods of discovering truth are perfectly his own; and that he has done more to render
theology a new science, than, with perhaps one or two exceptions, all the writers who have
lived since the days of the fathers.
Another characteristic of his controversial writings, is the excellent spirit which every
where pervades them. So strikingly is this true, that we cannot but urge every one, who
peruses them, to examine for himself, whether he can discover, in them all, a solitary deviation
from Christian kindness and sincerity. By such an examination he will discover in them, if
I mistake not, a fairness in proposing the real point in dispute, a candour in examining the
arguments of his opponents, in stating their objections, and in suggesting others in which
had escaped them, and a care in avoiding every thing like personality, and the imputation
of unworthy motives, rarely paralleled in the annals of controversy. It should here be re-
membered, that he wrote his treatise on the Affections, and his several works on revivals of
religion, in the very heat of a violent contest, which divided and agitated this whole country;
that in his treatises on the Freedom of the Will, on Original Sin, and on Justification, he
handles subjects, which unavoidably awaken the most bitter opposition in the human heart,
and opposes those, who had boasted of their victories over what he believed to be the cause
of truth, “with no little glorying and insult;” that his treatise on the Qualifications for
Communion, was written amid all the violence, and abuse, and injury of a furious parochial
controversy; and that, in the Answer to Williams, he was called to reply to the most gross
personalities, and to the most palpable misrepresentations of his arguments, his principles,
and his motives.
He has, I know, been charged sometimes with handling his antagonists with needless
severity. But let it be remembered, that his severity is never directed against their personal
character, but merely against their principles and arguments; that his wit is only an irresistible
403
CHAPTER XXV. Concluding remarks