In one direction it could lend itself to no
compromise; in spite of the justice done by Origen to the fundamental
ideas both of modalism and of emanative adoptionism (cf. Harnack, pp.
548, note, and 586), to Monarchianism in either form he is
diametrically opposed. The hypostatic distinctness of Son and Spirit is
once for all made good for the theology of Eastern Christendom. We see
his disciples exterminate Monarchianism in the East. On the left wing
Dionysius refutes the Sabellians of Libya, on the right Gregory
Thaumaturgus, Firmilian, and their brethren, after a long struggle,
oust the adoptionist Paul from the See of Antioch. But its influence on
the existing Catholic theology, however great (and in the East it was
very great), inevitably made its way in the face of opposition, and at
the cost of its original subtle consistency. The principal opposition
came from Asia Minor, where the traditions of theological thought (see
above, on Ignatius and Irenæus, below on Marcellus) were not in
sympathy Compare
the strong Origenist rejection of Chiliasm, the spiritualism of Origen
as contrasted with the realism of Asia Minor, the Asiatic origin of
Roman Monarchianism, of Montanism. with Origen. We cannot demonstrate the
existence of a continuous theological school in Asia; but Methodius
(270–300) certainly speaks with the voice of Ignatius and
Irenæus. He deals with Origen much as Irenæus dealt with the
Gnostics, defending against him the current sense of the regula
fidei, and especially the literal meaning of Scripture, the
origination of the soul along with the body, the resurrection of the
body in the material sense, and generally opposing realism to
the spiritualism of Origen. But in thus opposing Origen, Methodius is
not uninfluenced by him (see Socr. vi. 13). He, too, is a student of
Plato (with ‘little of his style or spirit’); his
‘realism’ is ‘speculative.’ He no longer
defends the Asiatic Chiliasm, his doctrine of the Logos is coloured by
Origen as that of Irenæus was by the Apologists. The legacy of
Methodius and of his Origenist contemporaries to the Eastern Church was
a modified Origenism, that is a theology systematised on the
intellectual basis of the Platonic philosophy, but expurgated by the
standard of the regula fidei. This result was a compromise, and
was at first attended with great confusion. Origen’s immediate
following seized some one side, some another of his system; some were
more, some less influenced by the ‘orthodox’ reaction
against his teaching. We may distinguish an Origenist
‘right’ and an Origenist ‘left.’ If the
Origenist view of the Universe was given up, the coeternity of the Son
and Spirit with the Father was less firmly grasped. Origen had, if we
may use the expression, ‘levelled up.’ The Son was mediator
between the Ingenerate God and the created, but eternal Universe. If
the latter was not eternal, and if at the same time the Word stood in
some essential correlation to the creative energy of God,
Origen’s system no longer implied the strict coeternity of the
Word. Accordingly we find Dionysius (see below, p. 173 sqq.) uncertain
on this point, and on the essential relation of the Son to the Father.
More cautious in this respect, but tenacious of other startling
features of Origen, were Pierius and Theognostus, who presided over the
Catechetical School at the end of the century The
position of Eusebius of Cæsarea is at the
‘extreme left’ of the Origenist body. (‘A reflex of
the unsolved problems of the Church of that time,’ Dorner.) It is
as though Dionysius instead of withdrawing and modifying his
incriminated statements, had involved them in a haze of explanations
and biblical phrases which left them where they were. But this is not
so much Arianism as confusion. ‘All is hollow and empty,
precarious and ambiguous. With a vast apparatus of biblical expressions
and the use of every possible formula, Monotheism is indeed maintained,
but practically a created subordinate God is inserted between God and
mankind’ (Harnack, p. 648). See also Dorner, Lehre der Pers.
Chr. Pt. 1, pp. 793–798. The language quoted by Ath. below,
p. 459, was doubtless meant by Eusebius in an Origenist
sense..