The
same man that is called a bishop just above is here called a presbyter.
It is such passages—and they are not uncommon in the early
Fathers—that have seemed to many to demonstrate conclusively the
original identity of presbyters and bishops, an identity which is
maintained by most Presbyterians, and is admitted by many Episcopalians
(e.g. by Lightfoot in his essay on the Christian Ministry, printed in
his Commentary on Philippians). On the other hand, the passages which
reveal a distinction between presbyters and bishops are very early, and
are adduced not merely by prelatists, but by such disinterested
scholars as Harnack (in his translation of Hatch’s
Organization of the Early Christian Churches) as proving that
there was from the beginning a difference of some sort between a bishop
and a presbyter. I cannot enter here into a discussion of the various
views in regard to the original relation between bishops and
presbyters. I desire simply to suggest a theory of my own, leaving the
fuller exposition of it for some future time. My theory is that the
word πρεσβύτερος
was originally employed in the most general sense to
indicate any church officer, thus practically equivalent to the
ἡγούμενος of Heb. xiii. 17, and the ποιμήν of Eph. iv. 11. The terms ἐπίσκοπος and δι€κονος, on the other hand, were employed to designate specific
church officers charged with the performance of specific duties. If
this were so, we should expect the general term to be used before the
particular designations, and this is just what we find in the New
Testament. We should expect further that the general term and the
specific terms might be used by the same person in the same context,
according as he thought of the officers in general or of a particular
division of the officers; on the other hand the general term and one of
the specific terms could never be coordinated (we could never find
“presbyter and bishop,” “presbyter and
deacon”), but we should expect to find the specific terms thus
coordinated (“bishops and deacons”). An examination
of the Epistle to the Philippians, of the Pastoral Epistles, of
Clement’s Epistle to the Corinthians, and of the Didache will
show that our expectations are fully realized. This theory explains the
fact that so frequently presbyters and bishops seem to be identical
(the general and the specific term might of course in many cases be
used interchangeably), and also the fact that so frequently they seem
to be quite distinct. It explains still further the remarkable fact
that while in the first century we never find a distinction in official
rank between bishops and presbyters, that distinction appears early in
the second. In many churches it must early have become necessary to
appoint some of the officers as a special committee to take charge of
the economic affairs of the congregation. The members of such a
committee might very naturally be given the special name ἐπίσκοποι (see Hatch’s discussion of the use of this word in his
work already referred to). In some churches the duties might be of such
a character that the bishops would need assistants (to whom it would be
natural to give the name δι€κονος), and such assistants would of course be closely associated
with the bishops, as we find them actually associated with them in the
second and following centuries (a fact which Hatch has emphasized). Of
course where the bishops constituted a special and smaller committee of
the general body, entrusted with such important duties, they would
naturally acquire especial influence and power, and thus the chairman
of the committee—the chairman of the bishops as such, not of the
presbyters, though he might be that also—would in time, as
a central authority was more and more felt to be necessary, gradually
assume the supremacy, retaining his original name ἐπίσκοπος. As the power was thus concentrated in his hands, the
committee of bishops as such would cease to be necessary, and he would
require only the deacons, who should carry out his directions in
economic matters, as we find them doing in the second century. The
elevation of the bishop would of course separate him from the other
officers in such a way that although still a presbyter (i.e. an
officer), he would cease to be called longer by the general name. In
the same way the deacons obliged to devote themselves to their specific
duties, would cease to have much to do with the more general functions
of the other officers, to whom finally the name
presbyter—originally a general term—would be confined, and
thus become a distinctive name for part of the officers. In their hands
would remain the general disciplinary functions which had belonged from
the beginning to the entire body of officers as such, and their rank
would naturally be second only to that of the bishop, for the deacons
as assistants only, not independent officers, could not outrank them
(though they struggled hard in the third and fourth centuries to do
so). It is of course likely that in a great many churches the simple
undivided office would long remain, and that bishops and deacons as
specific officers distinguished from the general body would not exist.
But after the distinction between the three orders had been sharply
drawn in one part of Christendom, it must soon spread throughout the
Church and become established even in places where it had not been
produced by a natural process of evolution. The Church organization of
the second century is thus complete, and its further development need
not concern us here, for it is not matter of controversy. Nor is this
the place to show how the local church officers gradually assumed the
spiritual functions which belonged originally to apostles, prophets,
and teachers. The Didache is the document which has shed most light
upon that process, and Hernack in his edition of it has done most to
make the matter clear.