Canon XV.
(
Greek
.)
Bishop
Hosius
said: And let us all decree this also,
that
399
if any bishop should ordain to any order
the minister of another from another diocese without the consent of his
own bishop, such an ordination should be accounted invalid and not
confirmed. And if any take upon themselves to do this they ought
to be admonished and corrected by our brethren and fellow-bishops.
All said: Let this decree also stand
unalterable.
(
Latin
.)
Bishop
Hosius
said: This also we all decree, that if any
[bishop] should ordain the minister of another from another diocese
without the consent and will of his own bishop, his ordination be not
ratified. And whoever shall have taken upon himself to do this
ought to be admonished and corrected by our brethren and
fellow-bishops.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon XV.
If one places a foreign minister without the
knowledge of his own bishop in any grade (
ἔμβαθμον
, in
aliquo gradu), he has indeed made the appointment, but it is without
force.
This is Canon XIX. in the Latin.
Hefele.
Fuchs, in his
Bibliothek der Kirchenversammlungen
(Pt. II., p. 123, note 125)
400
, thinks he has
discovered a difference between this canon and the exclusively Latin
one preceding it, in that the latter supposes the case of a bishop
ordaining a foreign cleric, over whom he has no jurisdiction, to a
higher grade, with the view of retaining him for his own diocese; while
the other—fifteenth or nineteenth canon—treats of a case
where such an ordination takes place without the ordaining bishop
intending to keep the person ordained for his own diocese. Van
Espen is of another opinion, and maintains that both canons obviously
refer to one and the same case, for which reason the Greek text has
only inserted one of them. It is certain that the text of both
canons, as we have it, does not clearly indicate the difference
conjectured by Fuchs, but that it may easily be found there.
Van Espen.
If the reading of all the Latins and Greeks is decisive,
this canon only treats of the ordination of those already ministers or
clerics, and so the Greek commentators Balsamon, Zonaras, and Aristenus
understood it, as is evident from their annotations. But Gratus,
Bishop of Carthage, and Primate of Africa, in the First Synod of
Carthage testified that in this canon it was decreed, that without the
licence of his own bishop, a layman of another diocese was not to be
ordained, and this interpretation or rather extension of the Canon, was
received everywhere, as is demonstrated by the fifty-sixth of the
African Code.
This together with Canon XIX. of the Latin text are
found as one in the
Corpus Juris Canonici
(Gratian’s
Decretum
, P. I., Dist. lxxj.), c. j.
399
The Greek text of
Bev. begins here.
400
The reference is given
incorrectly in the English Hefele.