All the Reformers in the outset, Melanchthon and Zwingle among them, adopted his
denial of free will and his doctrine of predestination, and sometimes even went beyond him
into the abyss of supralapsarianism, to cut out the last roots of human merit and boasting.
In this point Augustin holds the same relation to the Catholic church, as Luther to the
Lutheran; that is, he is a heretic of unimpeachable authority, who is more admired than
censured even in his extravagances; yet his doctrine of predestination was indirectly con-
demned by the pope in Jansenism, as Luther’s view was rejected as Calvinism by the Formula
of Concord.71 For Jansenism was nothing but a revival of Augustinianism in the bosom of
the Roman Catholic church.72
23
The excess of Augustin and the Reformers in this direction is due to the earnestness
and energy of their sense of sin and grace. The Pelagian looseness could never beget a re-
former. It was only the unshaken conviction of man’s own inability, of unconditional de-
pendence on God, and of the almighty power of his grace to give us strength for every good
work, which could do this. He who would give others the conviction that he has a divine
vocation for the church and for mankind, must himself be penetrated with the faith of an
eternal, unalterable decree of God, and must cling to it in the darkest hours.
new creation, and marks the epoch of modern Christianity which is different both from the mediæval and from
ancient or patristic Christianity.
71 It is well known that Luther, as late as 1526, in his work, De servo arbitrio, against Erasmus, which he
never retracted, proceeded upon the most rigorous notion of the divine omnipotence, wholly denied the freedom
of will, declared it a mere lie (merum mendacium), pronounced the calls of the Scriptures to repentance a divine
irony, and based eternal salvation and eternal perdition upon the secret will of God; in all this he almost exceeded
Calvin. See particulars in the books on doctrine-history; the inaugural dissertation of Jul. Müller: Lutheri de
prædestinatione et libero arbitrio doctrina, Gött. 1832; and a historical treatise on predestination by Carl Beck
in the “Studien und Kritiken” for 1847. We add, as a curiosity, the opinion of Gibbon (ch. xxxiii.), who, however,
had a very limited and superficial knowledge of Augustin: “The rigid system of Christianity which he framed
or restored, has been entertained, with public applause, and secret reluctance, by the Latin church. The church
of Rome has canonized Augustin, and reprobated Calvin. Yet as the real difference between them is invisible
even to a theological microscope, the Molinists are oppressed by the authority of the saint, and the Jansenists
are disgraced by their resemblance to the heretic. In the mean while the Protestant Arminians stand aloof, and
deride the mutual perplexity of the disputants. Perhaps a reasoner, still more independent, may smile in his turn
when he peruses an Arminian commentary on the Epistle to the Romans.” Nourrisson (ii. 179), from his Roman
stand-point, likewise makes Lutheranism to consist “essentiellement dans la question du libre arbitre.” But the
principle of Lutheranism, and of Protestantism generally, is the supremacy of the Holy Scriptures as a rule of
faith, and salvation by free grace through faith in Christ.
72 On the mighty influence of Augustin in the seventeenth century in France, especially on the noble
Jansenists, see the works on Jansenism, and also Nourrisson, l. c. tom. ii. pp. 186-276.
45
The Influence of St. Augustin on Posterity, and His Relation to Catholicism…