works effectually where it is believed and received as the truth of god.”—In another book,
(Benef. of the Gos. p. 149.) ” Common illumination does not convince men of the truth of
the gospel.”—In his discourse on the Virtue of Christ’s Blood, (p. 27.) speaking of such as
have no interest in the blood of Christ, he says, “They are strangers to the divine authority
of the word of god.” Again, (ibid. p. 16.) “Before [i.e. before saving faith] they were at a loss
526
whether the word was the word of god.”—To the like purpose are many other passages in
his writings. (See Nat. of Sav. Conv. p. 72. Safety of Ap. p. 6, 7, 99, 107, 186, 187, 229.—Benef.
of the Gosp. p. 89.)
So that here, if it be true, that some unconverted men have a divine warrant to come to
the Lord’s supper; and if the thing which is the foundation of this argument, be also true,
viz. That in order to men’s warrantably coming to the Lord’s supper, they must not only
think but know they have a right; then it must be true likewise, that they not only think but
know, that the Scripture, wherein this warrant is supposed to be delivered, is the word of
god. And then we have the following propositions to make hang together: that unconverted
men are ignorant of the Scripture’s being the word of God, are uncertain of it, have no as-
surance of it, are not convinced of it, do not properly believe it, are at a loss whether it be
the word of God, or not; and yet they not only think, but know, that the Scriptures are the
word of God, and that the gospel, which is the charter of all christian privileges, is divine;
they have a knowledge of it, which is above all probable hope or thought, and attended with
evidence above a thousand probabilities.
And now let it be considered, whether this agrees better with Mr. W.’s own doctrine,
concerning men’s knowing the truth and divine authority of the gospel, in what has been
before cited from his sermons on Christ a King and Witness. Where he expressly says, that
man, since the fall, is ignorant of the divine truth, and full of prejudices against it; has a view
of the truth contained in the Bible, as a doubtful uncertain thing; receives it as what is
probably true; sees it as a probable scheme, and something likely to answer the end proposed:
but that after conversion it appears divinely true and real. (See p. 114, 115, and 144.) Then
unconverted men only looked on the truth of the word of God, as probable, something
likely, yet as a doubtful uncertain thing; but now they not only think but know it to be true.
No distinction, about the different kinds of knowledge, or the various ways of knowing,
will ever help these absurdities, or reconcile such inconsistencies. If there be any such sort
of knowing, as is contra-distinguished to probable thinking, and to such opinion as is built
on a thousand probabilities, which yet is inconsistent with being ignorant, not believing,
being uncertain, nor assured, nor convinced, only looking on a thing probable, looking on
it doubtful and uncertain, it must certainly be a new and very strange sort of knowledge.
But this argument, that is so clear and invincible, must have such supports as these, or
must quite sink to the earth. It is indeed a remarkable kind of argument. It is not only as
much against the scheme it is brought to support, as against that which it would confute;
2020
SECTION XV. Of coming without a known right.