the middle, and then kindling the end torch1231), and were to maintain that the heat in the
first exceeded that of the others; that that next it showed a variation from it in the direction
of the less; and that the third could not be called fire at all, though it burnt and shone just
like fire, and did everything that fire does. But if there is really no hindrance to the third
torch being fire, though it has been kindled from a previous flame, what is the philosophy
of these men, who profanely think that they can slight the dignity of the Holy Spirit because
He is named by the Divine lips after the Father and the Son? Certainly, if there is in our
conceptions of the Substance of the Spirit anything that falls short of the Divine ideal, they
do well in testifying to His not possessing glory; but if the highness of His dignity is to be
perceived in every point, why do they grudge to make the confession of His glory? As if any
one after describing some one as a man, were to consider it not safe to go on to say of him
as well that he is reasoning, mortal, or anything else that can be predicated of a man, and
so were to cancel what he had just allowed; for if he is not reasoning, he is not a man at all;
but if the latter is granted, how can there be any hesitation about the conceptions already
implied in “man”? So, with regard to the Spirit, if when one calls Him Divine one speaks
the truth, neither when one defines Him to be worthy of honour, to be glorious, good, om-
nipotent, does one lie; for all such conceptions are at once admitted with the idea of Deity.
So that they must accept one of two alternatives; either not to call Him Divine at all, or to
refrain from subtracting from His Deity any one of those conceptions which are attributable
to Deity. We must then, most surely, comprehend along with each other these two thoughts,
viz. the Divine nature, and along with it a just idea, a devout intuition1232, of that Divine
and transcendent nature.
Since, then, it has been affirmed, and truly affirmed, that the Spirit is of the Divine Es-
sence, and since in that one word “Divine” every idea of greatness, as we have said, is involved,
it follows that he who grants that Divinity has potentially granted1233 all the rest;—the
gloriousness, the omnipotence, everything indicative of superiority. It is indeed a monstrous
thing to refuse to confess this in the case of the Spirit; monstrous, because of the incongruity,
as applied to Him, of the terms which in the list of opposites correspond to the above terms.
I mean, if one does not grant gloriousness, one must grant the absence of gloriousness; if
1231 “The Ancient Greek Fathers, speaking of this procession, mention the Father only, and never, I think,
express the Son, as sticking constantly in this to the language of the Scriptures (John xv. 26)”—Pearson. The
language of the above simile of Gregory would be an illustration of this. So Greg. Naz., Orat. I. de Filio, “standing
on our definitions, we introduce the Ungenerate, the Generated, and that which proceeds from the Father.”
This last expression was so known and public, that it is recorded even by Lucian in his Philopatris, §12.
1232 Reading καὶ τῆς εὐσεβοῦς ἐννοίας.
1233 The edition of Cardinal Mai has ὁ ἐκεῖνο δοὺς τῇ δυνάμει, συνωμολόγησε, κ. τ. λ. But the sense requires
the comma to be placed after δοὺς.
591
On the Holy Spirit.