“On their dictating this formula, we did not let it pass without inquiry in what sense
they introduced ‘of the substance of the Father,’ and ‘one in substance with the Father.’
Accordingly questions and explanations took place, and the meaning of the words underwent
the scrutiny of reason. And they professed that the phrase ‘of the substance’ was indicative
of the Son’s being indeed from the Father, yet without being as if a part of Him. And with
this understanding we thought good to assent to the sense of such religious doctrine,
teaching, as it did, that the Son was from the Father, not, however, a part of His substance.
On this account we assented to the sense ourselves, without declining even the term ‘One
in substance,’ peace being the object which we set before us, and steadfastness in the orthodox
view. In the same way we also admitted ‘begotten, not made’; since the Council alleged that
‘made’ was an appellative common to the other creatures which came to be through the
Son, to whom the Son had no likeness. Wherefore, said they, He was not a work resembling
the things which through Him came to be, but was of a substance which is too high for the
level of any work, and which the Divine oracles teach to have been generated from the
Father, the mode of generation being inscrutable and incalculable to every generated nature.
And so, too, on examination there are grounds for saying that the Son is ‘one in substance’
with the Father; not in the way of bodies, nor like mortal beings, for He is not such by division
of substance, or by severance; no, nor by any affection, or alteration, or changing of the
Father’s substance and power (since from all such the ingenerate nature of the Father is
alien), but because ‘one in substance with the Father’ suggests that the Son of God bears no
resemblance to the generated creatures, but that to His Father alone who begat Him is He
in every way assimilated, and that He is not of any other subsistence and substance, but
from the Father.
“To which term also, thus interpreted, it appeared well to assent; since we were aware
that, even among the ancients, some learned and illustrious Bishops and writers have used
the term ‘one in substance’ in their theological teaching concerning the Father and Son. So
much, then, be said concerning the faith which was published; to which all of us assented,
not without inquiry, but according to the specified senses, mentioned before the most reli-
gious Emperor himself, and justified by the fore-mentioned considerations. And as to the
anathematism published by them at the end of the Faith, it did not pain us, because it forbade
to use words not in Scripture, from which almost all the confusion and disorder of the
Church have come. Since, then, no divinely inspired Scripture has used the phrases, ‘out of
nothing’ and ‘once He was not,’ and the rest which follow, there appeared no ground for
using or teaching them; to which also we assented as a good decision, since it had not been
our custom hitherto to use these terms. Moreover, to anathematize ‘Before His generation
He was not’ did not seem preposterous, in that it is confessed by all that the Son of God was
before the generation according to the flesh. Nay, our most religious Emperor did at the
time prove, in a speech, that He was in being even according to His divine generation which
28
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.